help with 2 trade offers for hamilton

[soxx23]

im in a 8 team keeper league that can keep 12 every year that is a rotisserie league.we get points for hr,hit,walks,sb,runs for hitters and w,so,qs,loose points for loser for pitcher we start nine hitter w 9th as xh and 4 starter n 1 closer
c weiter and martin 1b pujols and howard 2b utley and espinosa 3b mcgehee and sandoval ss cabrera of hamilton,zobrist,stubbs,victrino,quentin,joyce,soriano and c young halladay,hanson,garcia,beckett,britton,correia and jordan zimmerman and jj putz are the pitchers i was offer youkilis and reyes for cabrera and hamilton or heyward and jennings for hamilton

[MaudDib]

No on both. In an 8 team league there is a lot more talent for teams so you should expect to get similar value for every player. While the Reyes deal is close, I like your side better. The other deal is way too risky for me. I like Heyward and Jennings but there is just too much we don't know about these guys to give up a talent like Hamilton for them.

[soxx23]

then can i ask two more questions which 12 would you keep and what do you think i could get for hamilton and weakest position i have

[MashinSpuds]

The other deal is way too risky for me. I like Heyward and Jennings but there is just too much we don't know about these guys to give up a talent like Hamilton for them.

Agreed on this. Unless you want to gamble on some young talent, then it's best to keep the outfield rock on your team. Your outfield isn't strong in certainties anyway, so stick with Hamilton.

[MashinSpuds]

... which 12 would you keep ...

I like these guys, even if Howard could be a little gimpy:

c weiters
1b pujols and howard
2b utley
3b sandoval
ss cabrera
of hamilton,zobrist,stubbs,victorino
sp halladay,hanson

[Urban Cohorts]

No on both of the trades.

Keepers-

Weiters C
Pujols 1B
Howard 1B
Utley 2B
Zobrist 2B/OF
Cabrera SS
Sandoval 3B
Hamilton OF
Victorino OF
Young OF

Halladay SP
Hanson SP

[MadDog36]

Weiters C
Pujols 1B
Howard 1B
Zobrist 2B
Cabrera SS
Sandoval 3B
Hamilton OF
Victorino OF
Young OF
Halladay SP
Hanson SP
Beckett SP

My keeps for you