baseballfanTigers wrote:Alright looks like its a consensus that I'm giving up too much.
Should I go the route Element suggested:
Is that more realistic?
Yes, this is much more reasonable. You wouldn't be trading away all of your picks so you would still have a good chance of drafting a guy who could become a decent keeper for you. And if you aren't in it to win it in 2012, upgrading your keeper list is fine.