Helton, Kent, and C. Jones vs. Huff, Soriano, Green

[Guest]

In H2H, which 3 would you rather have and why?

1b Helton
2b Kent
OF C. Jones

or

1b Huff
2b Soriano
OF Green

I have the 3rd pick in a 12 team, H2H, mixed league snake draft tonight. I'm considering devaluing saves in my draft, so I think I could end up with the Helton group above.

[sportznow]

I would rather have, Huff, Soriano and Green over Helton, Kent and Chipper because...
even though Helton is better than Huff i would rather have Huff. I really like him.
Soriano is better than Kent.
Green and Chipper are about even but I think Chippers numbers will drop with the absence of Javy Lopez and Gary Sheffield.

[L-Dawg]

I'd take the Helton group, you can make up steals with guys like Crawford later. However, you could also think about Soriano, Derrick Lee and Abreu that wouldn't be bad either.

[kaz]

Helton doesn't deserve a 3rd overall pick, take the Soriano group. Huff is great, Soriano can put up 40/40 and Green will be solid this year

[me]

chipper will benefit from sheff having left.
sheff batted 3rd last year, and chipper never had a mess to clean up!! now chipper bats 3rd, with andruw 4th...not a bad thing for those 2...worse for the bravos, yes.

[jpbusta]

I'd rather have helton's side.

[The Jury]

I'd rather have the Helton side mostly because of Shawn Green.. in that lineup even the best sluggers are limited.

[inkubus]

Huff/Soriano/Green.. all on one of my fantasy teams.

[rayt132]

i'd take the soriano group. with the third pick you should take soriano anyways and if not him vlad or beltran