Rate these pitchers

[MrT]

For mixed 12 team 5 x5 auction keeper league for this year only rate these pitchers:
H. Jansen $10, Sabathia $28, Haren $13, J Zimmerman $10, Gio Gonzalez $9, Matt Moore $10

[GreenMtn!]

In terms of value:

D. Haren $13
G. Gonzalez $9
M. Moore $10
CC Sabathia $28
Jansen $10 (do you mean Kenley Jansen?)

I think it might be a toss-up between Gio and Moore but I would say Gonzalez is the safer bet for this year.

[Element]

D. Haren $13


M. Moore $10
G. Gonzalez $9

CC Sabathia $28









K. Jansen $10

I'm taking Moore's upside at that dollar value over Gio. I'd be assuming that you can keep him cheaply moving forward of course.

[Broncmet724]

D. Haren $13


M. Moore $10
G. Gonzalez $9

CC Sabathia $28









K. Jansen $10

I'm taking Moore's upside at that dollar value over Gio. I'd be assuming that you can keep him cheaply moving forward of course.

This, although I don't think the disparity between CC and the two above him is quite so far

[MrT]

eveyone missed Zimmerman

[J35J]

D. Haren $13
M. Moore $10
G. Gonzalez $9
J. Zimmermann $10
CC Sabathia $28 (I don't like to spend top dollar on SP unless it's Kershaw or Halladay, and even then I'll let someone else pay it)


K. Jansen $10

[raiders_umpire]

Haren
Moore
Gonzalez
Zimmerman
Sabathia
Jansen

[Urban Cohorts]

D. Haren $13
M. Moore $10
G. Gonzalez $9
J. Zimmermann $10
CC Sabathia $28 (I don't like to spend top dollar on SP unless it's Kershaw or Halladay, and even then I'll let someone else pay it)


K. Jansen $10

I agree with this list

[lane_anasazi2]

Haren
Moore
Gonzalez
Zimmerman
Sabathia
Jansen

I think this is right. For me the tiers are:

Haren

Moore
Zimmerman
Gonzalez

Sabathia
Jansen

Reasons - Haren at that price is the best bet. Track record, talent, and he comes at a bargain. Moore, Zim, Geo - young, talented, good price. With Moore you're looking at way less of a track record but more ultimate upside (and his minors track record is just filthy). Sabathia you're not getting much value out of at that price. Jansen is a RP making him really to spend double digits on.

[MrT]

Everyone is pretty consistent with the tip 4. I think that if Jansen becomes a closer he moves up that list.