Who to keep? WHIR

[Warrior24]

I am in an 12-team H2H league. We get to choose between 12 to 18 keepers. This past season my team won the championship. I am looking to make trades, but if I am not able to, who should I keep?

C Matt Wieters
1B Michael Morse
2B Chase Utley
SS Starlin Castro
3B Adrian Beltre
IF Adam Lind
LF Desmond Jennings
CF BJ Upton
RF Cory Hart
OF Jason Heyward
Util Billy Butler
Bench
Mike Trout
Carlos Quentin
Lance Berkman
Leonys Martin

Pitching
Roy Halladay
Clayton Kershaw
James Shields
Madison Bumgarner
Jeremy Hellickson
Jonathon Papelbon
Chris Perez
Matt Moore
Clay Buchholz
Vinnie Pestano
Grant Balfour
Jim Johnson

Please Leave Links

[GiantsFan14]

I am in an 12-team H2H league. We get to choose between 12 to 18 keepers. This past season my team won the championship. I am looking to make trades, but if I am not able to, who should I keep?

C Matt Wieters
1B Michael Morse
2B Chase Utley
SS Starlin Castro
3B Adrian Beltre
IF Adam Lind
LF Desmond Jennings
CF BJ Upton
RF Cory Hart
OF Jason Heyward
Util Billy Butler
Bench
Mike Trout
Carlos Quentin
Lance Berkman
Leonys Martin

Pitching
Roy Halladay
Clayton Kershaw
James Shields
Madison Bumgarner
Jeremy Hellickson
Jonathon Papelbon
Chris Perez
Matt Moore
Clay Buchholz
Vinnie Pestano
Grant Balfour
Jim Johnson

Please Leave Links

Last spot goes to Hellickson or Papelbon. Since you keep so many and you already have 5 very good starters, I'd go with Papelbon. Pretty sick team though.

[Element]

^^^^ I'm 100% on board with this.

[Urban Cohorts]

Yeah I like the list Giantsfan posted too

[Warrior24]

I'm looking to package people for a 1B. Anything else I should target?

[MashinSpuds]

If you won the championship, hang onto the championship team. GiantsFan gets it. As for what else to target, I bet you could package a couple of mid-tier hitters for a stronger OF candidate.

[ensanimal]

Go with gf's recommendations.

1B isn't a big problem for you, you've got a few good options. Obviously if you can package a couple of guys for one of the true studs, go for it. Same feelings in the OF.

[lane_anasazi2]

Go with gf's recommendations.

1B isn't a big problem for you, you've got a few good options. Obviously if you can package a couple of guys for one of the true studs, go for it. Same feelings in the OF.

Can't find a thing wrong with GF's recs. When you have a powerhouse team like that, the thing to do is trade two mid-tier guys for a better keeper. Consolidate talent; if you have guys that you aren't keeping that would be keepers for other teams, it's an opportunity.

[MaudDib]

Yeah I like the list Giantsfan posted too