Cafe consensus Top 50 for 2012?

[WaCougMBS]

Time to fire this bad boy up again

Is someone spearheading this project for this season? If not, I might be able to co-coordinate with someone if we could get 5-10 rankers and crank something out in the next couple of weeks. If there's one in the works somewhere and I missed it somehow, I'd love to participate (or at least utilize if I'm too late for that) so let me know if you know anything

[silverZ]

I would love to help, but since I play an AL-only league I know almost nothing about NL prospects. I look forward to reading other peoples rankings though.

[PlayingWithFire]

I have a list now, what to do?

[Tennessee Jed]

I have a list now, what to do?

post it!

[PlayingWithFire]

1. Matt Moore-P-TB
2. Bryce Harper-OF-Was
3. Mike Trout-OF-Ana
4. Trevor Bauer-P-Ari
5. Jesus Montero-C-Sea
6. Jurickson Profar-SS-Tex
7. Julio Teheran-P-Atl
8. Manny Machado-SS-Bal
9. Shelby Miller-P-Stl
10. Devin Mesoraco-C-Cin
11. Dylan Bundy-P-Bal
12. Jameson Taillon-P-Pit
13. Nolan Arenado-3B-Col
14. Yonder Alonso-1B-SD
15. James Paxton-P-Sea
16. Tyler Skaggs-P-Ari
17. Anthony Rendon-3B-Was
18. Bubba Starling-OF-KC
19. Archie Bradley-P-Ari
20. Will Myers-OF-KC
21. Jacob Turner-P-Det
22. Jarrod Parker-P-Oak
23. Travis D’Arnaud-C-Tor
24. Taijuan Walker-P-Sea
25. Miguel Sano-3B-Min
26. Danny Hultzen-P-Sea
27. Francisco Lindor-SS-Cle
28. Carlos Martinez-P-Stl
29. Anthony Rizzo-1B-ChC
30. Randall Delgado-P-Atl
31. Jake Marisnick-OF-Tor
32. Yasmani Grandal-C-SD
33. Jean Segura-2B-Ana
34. Xander Bogaerts-SS-Bos
35. Hak-Ju Lee-SS-TB
36. Jonathan Schoop-2B-Bal
37. AJ Cole-P-Oak
38. Gary Brown-OF-SF
39. Drew Pomeranz-P-Col
40. Martin Perez-P-Tex
41. Chrstian Yelich-OF-Mia
42. Michael Choice-OF-Oak
43. Gerrit Cole-P-Pit
44. Jake Odorizzi-P-KC
45. Nick Franklin-SS-Sea
46. Cheslor Cuthbert-3B-KC
47. Jonathan Singleton-1B-Hou
48. George Springer-OF-Hou
49. Brad Peacock-P-Oak
50. Andrelton Simmons-SS-Atl

[TheBull]

what is profar's upside? Not sure if this post belong's here...i Have have the 7th overall pick "start-up" draft....

Can anyone give me a list of SP you would rather draft besides "the best avail"

[PlayingWithFire]

what is profar's upside? Not sure if this post belong's here...i Have have the 7th overall pick "start-up" draft....

Can anyone give me a list of SP you would rather draft besides "the best avail"

Profar's upside is very much in debate. I just don't see it. So I'll say .280/.360 20HR type. Not bad, perennial all star but not a superstar.

Don't understand your 2nd sentence and quite disappointed at the lack of lists.

[TurdFerguson]

I agree with PWF.. Profar's upside will depend on a lot if he can fill out.. He is still only 18 years old.. I think Profar has .300 20-20 type of ceiling but a lot will come down to how he matures physically.. If he does watch out because the kid could be a truly elite SS.. Either way the kid is an elite talent and has a bright future..

[MasterX1918]

1-Matt Moore (P)-TB
2-Mike Trout (OF)-LAA
3-Bryce Harper (OF)- WAS
4-Julio Teheran (P)-ATL
5-Shelby Miller (P)-STL
6-Jesus Montero (OF)-SEA
7-Manny Machado (SS)-BAL
8-Jurickson Profar (SS)-TEX
9-Jameson Taillon (P)-PIT
10-Wil Myers (OF)-KC
11-Devin Mesoraco (C)-CIN
12-Jacob Turner (P)-DET
13-Trevor Bauer (P)-ARI
14-Gerrit Cole (P)-PIT
15-Dylan Bundy (P)-BAL
16-Nolan Arenado (3B)-COL
17-Tyler Skaggs (P)-ARI
18-Drew Pomeranz (P)-COL
19-Anthony Rendon (3B)-WAS
20-Jarrod Parker (P)-ARI
21-Taijuan Walker (P)-SEA
22-Anthony Rizzo (1B)-CHC
23-Danny Hultzen (P)-SEA
24-Carlos Martinez (P)-STL
25-Bubba Starling (OF)-KC
26-Archie Bradley (P)-ARI
27-Martin Perez (P)-TEX
28-Yonder Alonso (1B)-SD
29-Miguel Sano (3B)-MIN
30-Arodys Vizcaino (P)-ATL
31-Manny Banuelos (P)-NYY
32-Randall Delgado (P)-ATL
33-Jon Singleton (1B/OF)-HOU
34-Jake Odorizzi (P)-KC
35-Xander Boegarts (SS)-BOS
36-Travis D'Arnaud (C)- TOR
37-Christian Yellich (OF)-FLA
38-Matt Harvey (P)-NYM
39-Oscar Tavaras (OF)-STL
40-James Paxton (P)-SEA
41-Brett Jackson (OF)-CHC
42-Josh Bell (OF)-PIT
43-Billy Hamilton (SS)-CIN
44-George Springer (OF)-HOU
45-Zach Wheeler (P)-NYM
46-Jake Marisnick (OF)-TOR
47-Dellin Betances (P)-NYY
48-Trevor May (P)-PHI
49-Nick Franklin (SS)-SEA
50-Gary Brown (OF)-SF


list is still preliminary and tentative to change, Moore/Trout/Harper is a tight top 3 and any of those guys could be #1. The rest of the list still feels like a mess, I feel like I have some guys too high (Tavaras, Cole, Jackson) and others too low (D'Arnaud, Grandal, Cuthbert)

last edit made on feb 7

[PlayingWithFire]

I'm just glad there is a 2nd list. I probably need to revise mine too. D'Arnaud and Mesoraco shouldn't be that far apart.