Giantsfan14's Projections and Rankings (updated 2/10)

[Curtis Pride]

Amazing work.

OPS?

if you went through and projected doubles and triples the spreadsheet could calculate it. maybe i'll include that next year.

Yeah, if you could include doubles and triples in the projections, I could include this in my Wisdom of the Crowds thing.

[Mookie4ever]

Updated with SP (rankings only done to about 60 or so, and roughly at that)

Let me know if I'm missing anyone or if anyone looks like their in a bad spot based on my projections.

Awesome....but I think you may hear something about Halladay not even being the top ranked pitcher on his own team.
Don't know why but I have a suspicion someone's head may assplode.

[GiantsFan14]

Updated with SP (rankings only done to about 60 or so, and roughly at that)

Let me know if I'm missing anyone or if anyone looks like their in a bad spot based on my projections.

Awesome....but I think you may hear something about Halladay not even being the top ranked pitcher on his own team.
Don't know why but I have a suspicion someone's head may assplode.

It's really close and if I had to choose one straight up I'd go with Halladay. I'd much prefer to take Lee mid-3rd than Halladay mid-2nd though.

SP rankings are pretty much done, hopefully there aren't any glaring mistakes.

[Norby]

What's the thinking behind Bumgarner at 10?

Most rankings/projections have him in the 20-30 range.

Personally, i think i need to see another year from Bumgarner before i rate him that high. I think Cain would be the safer choice for that spot, with a chance to rate higher when the Giants actually score more than 1 run for him.

[J35J]

What's the thinking behind Bumgarner at 10?

Most rankings/projections have him in the 20-30 range.

Personally, i think i need to see another year from Bumgarner before i rate him that high. I think Cain would be the safer choice for that spot, with a chance to rate higher when the Giants actually score more than 1 run for him.

I'd guess because Giants is a Giants fan and he's a homer..... I keed, I keed



Actually, I've got him in the 12-15 range myself. He's 22 years old, had the pedigree from the start and had over 4 K/BB ratio, a 2.67FIP and a 3.10xFIP. He also gets to pitch in the NL West. What's not to like?

[GiantsFan14]

What's the thinking behind Bumgarner at 10?

Most rankings/projections have him in the 20-30 range.

Personally, i think i need to see another year from Bumgarner before i rate him that high. I think Cain would be the safer choice for that spot, with a chance to rate higher when the Giants actually score more than 1 run for him.

I'd guess because Giants is a Giants fan and he's a homer..... I keed, I keed



Actually, I've got him in the 12-15 range myself. He's 22 years old, had the pedigree from the start and had over 4 K/BB ratio, a 2.67FIP and a 3.10xFIP. He also gets to pitch in the NL West. What's not to like?

I am a homer indeed. Even so, the kid put up the 4th best FIP and 7th best xFIP among all starters last year and had a 4.15 K/BB as a freaking 21 year old. He's got huge potential and he showed it in the second half when he went 9-4 with a 2.70 ERA, 1.09 WHIP, and 114 Ks in 113 innings. Cain might be a safer pick but he doesn't have the potential for greatness that Bumgarner has.

[J35J]

He's got huge potential and she showed it in the second half

That was a low blow...

[GiantsFan14]

He's got huge potential and she showed it in the second half

That was a low blow...

no clue what you're talking about...

[jtsandwich]

Well done. For next yr you may want to add auction values.

[GiantsFan14]

Well done. For next yr you may want to add auction values.

Done thanks to TheRock who took my numbers and calculated auction values based on a shallow 12 team league starting 9 hitters (C, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, OF, OF OF, UTIL) and adjusted for positional scarcity.

Some of the guys weren't on the spreadsheet i sent him which is why i don't have values for them yet. pitching will be up when he gets a chance to do it.