Trade involving Pineda and young OF's whir!

[GaborikNYR]

12 Team 5x5 Roto 1250ip limit 10 player keeper league

Based purely on a value standpoint, disregarding my current roster, should I trade Michael Pineda for any of the following players?

I trade away Pineda and get one of BJ Upton, Desmond Jennings, MIke Napoli or Alex Gordon.

What do you guys think?

[ayebatter]

for 2012
Upton
Gordon
Napoli

Pineda

Jennings

[kidsilk]

I think I would take any of those guys for Pineda.

I would rank them:

Napoli
Upton
Gordon
Jennings

for this year at least

please help

viewtopic.php?t=437842

[bigh0rt]

I'd take one of Napoli or Gordon for him definitely, depending on need and/or belief in one of them repeating their 2011. I'd probably take Jennings as well, but I'm a guy who is pretty sour on BJ Upton.

[GaborikNYR]

Honestly, I'm kind of wondering why you guys aren't higher on Jennings or Gordon. They were the top two options in my mind.

Any reason you guys don't think Jennings or Gordon are my best two options here? Jennings could turn into a star, no?

[HOOTIE]

Napoli or Jennings

[raiders_umpire]

I would take any of the 4 for Pineda.

[Urban Cohorts]

I would take any of the 4 for Pineda.

Have to agree here. I like Napoli and Gordon the most of the bunch.

[GiantsFan14]

I would take any of the 4 for Pineda.

Have to agree here. I like Napoli and Gordon the most of the bunch.

pretty much this. i like napoli more than the others by a decent margin.

[ensanimal]

I would take any of the 4 for Pineda.

Agree with this. Depends on what my roster would need to decide between them. I'm still a believer in Upton (I swear this is the last year I'll say this).