Which keeper scenario do you prefer?

[TheGhost]

Stanton, Hosmer, Pineda, Trout, Andrus, Morse
the other scenario is...
Stanton, Hosmer, Pineda, Trout, Bruce, Castro

[Urban Cohorts]

I'll say the same as in the other thread-

I go with Castro + Bruce over Andrus + Morse. I think with the rounds you have to give up, they come out nearly even value wise. But I personally see Morse regressing, which is why I like the Bruce/Castro side.

That and if you keep both Bruce and Stanton (two stud OF), you won't have to draft Cargo back in the 1st round. You can take someone else instead.

Also, you may get more responses to this question if you make it a poll

[lane_anasazi2]

I don't see anything about rounds or having Cargo. Also the first group of players is the same, so why does it matter?

If the question is, would you rather keep Andrus/Morse over Castro/Bruce, then I'd take Castro/Bruce by a landslide.

Is there more information in another thread? That seems like a bad idea.

[ensanimal]

Bruce/Castro for sure out of the options given.

[bigh0rt]

Bruce and Castro for me.

[ayebatter]

Bruce/Castro

[HOOTIE]

[quote="TheGhost"]Stanton, Hosmer, Pineda, Trout, Andrus, Morse
the other scenario is...
Stanton, Hosmer, Pineda, Trout, Bruce, Castro[/quote

Why not keep
Andrus, Morse, Bruce, Castro
and forget Trout and Pineda?

[raiders_umpire]

None of the above. It is easily these 6 imo

OF: Mike Stanton (8th rd.)
OF: Michael Morse (22nd rd.)
UTL: Eric Hosmer (23rd rd.)
BN:Starlin Castro (17th rd.)
Michael Pineda (22nd rd.),
Matt Garza (19th rd.),

[rdd121robroy]

None of the above. It is easily these 6 imo

OF: Mike Stanton (8th rd.)
OF: Michael Morse (22nd rd.)
UTL: Eric Hosmer (23rd rd.)
BN:Starlin Castro (17th rd.)
Michael Pineda (22nd rd.),
Matt Garza (19th rd.),

I like this list but I might consider Berkman over Pineda or Garza. If you drafted Garza that late last year I assume there will be good pitching bargains this year too. To answer the original question I would go Bruce/Castro.

[MaudDib]

Bruce/Castro for sure out of the options given.

Not even really a question IMO.