I'm not quite sure how Jeremy Burnitz and Brad Radke even get on the ballot and Albert Belle is nowhere to be found.
I guess I'm alone on Mattingly. I think there needs to be a human element to the hall as well, otherwise why vote? Why not just let computers select the players? I don't think his fame came from being the only good Yankee. It helped, but I wasn't a Yankees fan, my friends weren't Yankees fans, ESPN wasn't around (or at least on enough TVs) to tell everyone he was awesome because he was a Yankee. He was just somebody everybody liked watching and he was really good. Other than McGwire, there is no other player eligible that had the universal appeal of Mattingly. That has to count for something.