12 team 5x5 standard roto league, 1500 IP limit Our roster positions are C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, IF, 4 OF, Util, 3 SP, 3 RP, 3 P, 7 Bench, 2 DL keep any 10 players indefinitely...these 10 keepers are your picks for rounds 1 through 10
These are my keepers right now...
1) C Carlos Santana (Cle - C,1B) 2) 1B Adrian Gonzalez (Bos - 1B) 3) 2B Robinson Canó (NYY - 2B) 4) 3B Jose Bautista (Tor - 3B,OF) 5) IF Eric Hosmer (KC - 1B) 6) SS Troy Tulowitzki (Col - SS) 7) SP Zack Greinke (Mil - SP) 8) SP Justin Verlander (Det - SP) 9) SP Stephen Strasburg (Was - SP) 10) Brett Gardner, Andre Ethier, or Brandon Beachy
Please evalutate these 3 trades for me...
My Tulo and one of Gardner, Ethier, Beachy for his Andrus and Cliff Lee or My Bautista and one of Gardner, Ethier, Beachy for his Lawrie and Kershaw or My Tulo and one of Gardner, Ethier, Beachy for his Hanley and Bumgarner or Josh Johnson
Last edited by onitapgr on Sun Dec 04, 2011 11:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
That first trade is a big thumbs down. Downgrading a bunch at SS and giving up a useful OF/SP in order to get a good SP who isn't exactly young: not a good move.
The second trade is better. You're giving up the best player now for two guys who'll most likely be better for a longer stretch. Lawrie and Kershaw are both excellent keepers. This move makes sense to me. Kershaw is an elite talent and Lawrie has superstar potential.
I like your 7-3 H/P mix better than the 6/4 w Kershaw and as such would stand pat. I certainly think Andrus is a keeper in this format but wouldn't trade Tulo. The 2nd trade is fair enough I just wouldn't swap what you have
When asking for roster advice in these pages, remember there are thousands of different sets of league rules & many different active roster settings. If you want the best replies, be sure to include your leagues particulars in the original post
onitapgr wrote:My Tulo and one of Gardner, Ethier, Beachy for his Andrus and Cliff Lee
This deal isn't even close for me. I think Andrus does remain a keeper, but you're giving up the best SS and then some for SS who will help you in 3 categories and an elite, yet old SP.
My Bautista and one of Gardner, Ethier, Beachy for his Lawrie and Kershaw
This deal is closer, but I still would not accept. Kershaw is gold, but you already have a top notch SP core in Greinke, Verlander, and Strasburg. Lawrie has potential, but it is just that- potential. I wouldn't call him a top 3B yet- he hasn't played a full season. Bautista is the top 3B and one of the best. If Lawrie was a little more proven and you didn't have a great SP core, I would be tempted. But as is, your keepers make your team a SET contender. No way do I deal away a top player in that for youth.
My Tulo and one of Gardner, Ethier, Beachy for his Hanley and Bumgarner or Josh Johnson
Not a terrible deal, but I wouldn't take it.
I guess it depends how much faith you have in Hanley. He will probably lose SS eligibility at some point... though maybe not. Who thinks Reyes will be 100% injury free? And when Reyes is down, I would imagine Hanley moves back over to get enough for the minimum requirement (at least for Yahoo). Bumgarner is high upside, but your SP is set. JJ is coming back from missing a season. Not worth much, let alone a Tulo deal, until he can prove he is healthy.
My Tulo and one of Gardner, Ethier, Beachy for his Hanley and Bumgarner or Josh Johnson?
I wouldn't do this trade either. Hanley had an off year and has to show that he can bounce back. Also with Reyes going to Miami, Hanley may be traded or moved over to 3rd. Bumgarner is good, but he hasn't reached elite status yet. Johnson is just a big injury risk, until he completes a season without major DL time, I would not put too much stock in him.