Pick 4

[Tavish]

Mark Teixeira, NYY 1B
Evan Longoria, TB 3B
Prince Fielder, Mil 1B
David Price, TB SP

Homer

[Pogotheostrich]

1) Evan Longoria, TB 3B
2) Prince Fielder, Mil 1B
3) Mark Teixeira, NYY 1B

I'd take my chances with the draft for the 4th pick.

[raiders_umpire]

Mark Teixeira, NYY 1B
Evan Longoria, TB 3B
Prince Fielder, Mil 1B
David Price, TB SP

Homer

True. But at least they are somewhat close, and Price took a pretty huge step forward this year even though luck was not on his side like it was 2010. It is not like I told you to keep Wade Davis over Halladay.

[lane_anasazi2]

1) Evan Longoria, TB 3B
2) Prince Fielder, Mil 1B
3) Mark Teixeira, NYY 1B

I'd take my chances with the draft for the 4th pick.

I like this option. Tough to really press for it since I don't know your league, but I'm not thrilled enough with CC that I wouldn't mind taking a risk here.

[Urban Cohorts]

So this is for a friendly league that I honestly don't care too much about but instead of dropping out I will just play it as a Cafe consensus team next year (any moves other than basic add / drop I will just do the Cafe's bidding).

This part screams POLL!

Looks like you have 2 options here- Keep CC as the 4th or keep 3 and try to get better!

[Tavish]

Poll has been added.

[ensanimal]

I missed the original part about not keeping all 4. If you can gauge what some teams "may" do, I would potentially risk it and go with three keepers and grab the best in your first round. Worst case, it blows up in your face, but at least you have all of us to blame, and then we can help you make up for it in-season.