Keeper League Trade

[raiders_umpire]

I prefer Kemp slightly to Cabrera

I know you are a Dodgers fan, but come on now, really?

Kemp had an MVP season for sure, but Miggy has been a top 5 stud for years now. And 1B is slightly more shallow than OF.

If Kemp repeats his 2011 performance in 2012, I would agree that they are in the same class. But until that happens, I'm taking Miggy over Kemp all day.

I see nothing wrong with somebody preferring Kemp to Cabrera.

[Pogotheostrich]

I prefer Kemp slightly to Cabrera

I know you are a Dodgers fan, but come on now, really?

Kemp had an MVP season for sure, but Miggy has been a top 5 stud for years now. And 1B is slightly more shallow than OF.

If Kemp repeats his 2011 performance in 2012, I would agree that they are in the same class. But until that happens, I'm taking Miggy over Kemp all day.

I see nothing wrong with somebody preferring Kemp to Cabrera.

I prefer M-Cab because IMO he is the safer more consistant pick but I can easily see why someone would prefer Kemp.

[Urban Cohorts]

I prefer M-Cab because IMO he is the safer more consistant pick

That hits the nail on the head for me. Miggy has been a top 5 fantasy star for years now. He may be regressing, but until Kemp can post another performance that is close to 2011, I'm still taking Miggy.

Kemp is on the rise, as he is in his prime. But with such dramatic increases across the board, I'd rather spend my 1st round pick elsewhere. Same deal for Ellsbury. And as of now, I still like Pujols, Braun, Tulo, and Miggy as my top 4.

[ensanimal]

MCab/Wright.

MCab>Kemp barely. Security at the top is of utmost importance.

[converge241]

Miggy adding 3B, I feel silly to even have questioned it now