Desmond Jennings for Tommy Hanson?

[LordMattius]

I have plenty of OF to keep.
my only pitching keepers are lester and hamels.
Jennings for Hanson?

I also rejected his: gardner, braun and arod
for my tulo, agoz, and jennings.

right rejection right. i don't have another 1b on my roster other than agoz (morse too) but still.

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd rather have Jennings. If Hanson shoulder is 100% it is closer but I still prefer Jennings.

[raiders_umpire]

Solid rejection on the other trade. As far as Jennings for Hanson, it is very close. Lester and Hamels is a solid start to a staff, but does Jennings possible 40 steals pose a bigger need for your team. Jennings will play great defense, steal some bases, and have a pretty good OBP, but his average and power will leave some to be desired. Which brings the question, who are the rest of your keepers.

[lane_anasazi2]

Yeah we'd need to know the keeper structure and the rest of your keepers. League settings wouldn't hurt either. Jennings would be more valuable in an OBP league, I'd guess.

All things being equal I'd rather keep Jennings. Hitting > pitching, especially pitching with health questions. Even if you "plenty" of OF, in a league with the right keeper structure Jennings is a big trade chip. Chances are you can address a different need, preferably snagging a young, talented hitter. Ackley or Lawrie - someone whose position you don't have "plenty" of.

[MaudDib]

As much as I like Hanson, I think you need to keep Jennings here. Right now I think Jennings is over-rated and would look to move him but Hanson hasn't shown to be healthy enough.

[chargerss24]

I always favor bats over arms. ESPECIALLY arms coming off an injury.

No.

[RedHopeful]

I always favor bats over arms. ESPECIALLY arms coming off an injury.

No.

ESPECIALLY shoulder injuries.

[Niffoc4]

I always favor bats over arms. ESPECIALLY arms coming off an injury.

No.

ESPECIALLY shoulder injuries.

This is the key. Trading Jennings for an SP isn't a bad idea, but Hanson's shoulder scares me.

[Urban Cohorts]

Seems to be getting redundant here, but I'm also in favor of Jennings over Hanson. If you want a SP, you can do better than Hansen, whose stock has certainly fallen since the injury.

[LordMattius]

Roster:
C Alex Avila, Det C K DTD
137/464 63 19 56 82 73 3 .295 .389 -1.46 99.6 -0.4
1B Adrian Gonzalez, Bos 1B K
213/630 108 27 75 117 74 1 .338 .410 4.83 100.0 +0
2B Ian Kinsler, Tex 2B, DH K
158/620 121 32 70 77 89 30 .255 .355 11.54 100.0 +0
3B Jose Bautista, Tor 3B, OF K
155/513 105 43 69 103 132 9 .302 .447 3.58 100.0 +0
SS Troy Tulowitzki, Col SS K DTD [Breaking News]
162/537 81 30 68 105 59 9 .302 .372 -4.92 86.4 -7.1
2B/SS Emilio Bonifacio, Fla OF, 3B, SS
167/565 78 5 38 36 59 40 .296 .360 7.62 99.2 +0.3
1B/3B Adrian Beltre, Tex 3B, DH K
144/487 82 32 65 105 25 1 .296 .331 18.45 100.0 +0
OF Nelson Cruz, Tex OF K DTD
125/475 64 29 58 87 33 9 .263 .312 -3.28 98.5 -1.5
OF Michael Bourn, Atl OF K
193/656 94 2 46 50 53 61 .294 .349 4.52 100.0 +0
OF Michael Morse, Was OF, 1B K
158/522 73 31 67 95 36 2 .303 .360 7.37 100.0 +0
OF Desmond Jennings, TB OF K
64/247 44 10 23 25 31 20 .259 .356 3.65 100.0 +0
OF
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
UTIL J.J. Hardy, Bal SS K
142/527 76 30 57 80 31 0 .269 .310 10.25 96.9 -0.1
Bench Jason Heyward, Atl OF K DTD
90/396 50 14 34 42 51 9 .227 .319 1.76 74.5 +2.9
DL
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
DL
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
PITCHERS 2011 SEASON Pitching RESEARCH
SLOT PLAYER, TEAM POS ACTION IP H ER BB K W SV HD ERA WHIP K/9 PR15 %OWN +/-
P Tim Hudson, Atl SP
215.0 189 77 56 158 16 0 0 3.22 1.14 6.61 5.48 99.8 -0.2
P John Axford, Mil RP K
73.2 59 16 25 86 2 46 0 1.95 1.14 10.51 4.86 99.4 -0.6
P Jon Lester, Bos SP K
191.2 166 74 75 182 15 0 0 3.47 1.26 8.55 -2.87 100.0 +0
P Kyle Farnsworth, TB RP [Recent News]
57.2 45 14 12 51 5 25 0 2.18 0.99 7.96 3.71 80.9 +9.4
P David Robertson, NYY RP
66.2 40 8 35 100 4 1 34 1.08 1.13 13.50 2.61 18.1 +0.8
P Antonio Bastardo, Phi RP
58.0 28 17 26 70 6 8 17 2.64 0.93 10.86 -2.33 22.0 -2.1
P Grant Balfour, Oak RP
62.0 44 17 20 59 5 2 26 2.47 1.03 8.56 1.30 1.6 +0.2
P Eric O'Flaherty, Atl RP
73.2 59 8 21 67 2 0 32 0.98 1.09 8.19 1.68 6.3 +3.7
P Vance Worley, Phi RP, SP
131.2 116 44 46 119 11 0 2 3.01 1.23 8.13 0.35 66.3 -24.7
Bench Cole Hamels, Phi SP K DTD [Recent News]
216.0 169 67 44 194 14 0 0 2.79 0.99 8.08 2.09 95.4 -4.6
Bench Johnny Cueto, Cin SP
156.0 123 40 47 104 9 0 0 2.31 1.09 6.00 -- 71.6 -7.6
Bench Javier Vazquez, Fla SP [Breaking News]
192.2 178 79 50 162 13 0 0 3.69 1.18 7.57 11.21 71.7 -7.6
Bench Ryan Vogelsong, SF RP, SP