2011 Season Over, looking at 2012 keepers

[octagon999]

In a fairly standard 12 Team H2H mixed league, we can keep four from year to year, with no restrictions.

I think three are certain:
Kemp
Reyes
Longoria

The fourth is the one I'm struggling with. The ones I'm considering the most are:
Mike Stanton (Seems like a great long-term prospect)
Buster Posey (kept this last year, but injury concerns)
Jered Weaver (nervous about keeping a pitcher, but great numbers)
Javier Vazquez (finished the season great)
Adrian Beltre (older but he really performed this year)
Lucas Duda (see Stanton)
David Murphy (really came on late in the season)

Would appreciate your thoughts and insight.

[FantasySportsMaven]

Out of those I think I'd keep Weaver since you already are keeping 3 good hitters. Otherwise, I'd probably take a chance and go with Murphy, since he kicked butt late in the year and has multiple position eligibility.

Help me too? viewtopic.php?t=436950

[onitapgr]

Out of those I think I'd keep Weaver since you already are keeping 3 good hitters. Otherwise, I'd probably take a chance and go with Murphy, since he kicked butt late in the year and has multiple position eligibility.

Help me too? viewtopic.php?t=436950

Murphy over Stanton? No way.....I would keep Stanton here.....Weaver is replaceable.

[oakscorps]

Weaver easily