What do you think of this deal in a keeper? WHIR

[Guzman24]

We play in a 12 team league 5x5 (OBP instead of AVG & QS instead of W's) We keep 8

Thinking of offering this deal as a keeper swap:

I send: Reyes,Teixeira,Price
I get: JUpton, Kershaw

How do you like it for right now and in the future? As things stand right now my keepers for next year are in bold. So basically I'd be swapping Reyes and Teix for Upton and Kershaw on the keeper front.

C Montero
1B Votto
2B Kipnis (DL Weeks)
SS Peralta (DL Reyes)
3B Young
OF Kemp,Holliday,Granderson
UT Teix

SP Verlander,Price,Bumgarner,Gio,Garza
RP Kimbrel,Walden

BN J.Johnson, Norris, Cordero, Maybin

[germani40]

Just by looking at this I dont think the other guy will accept it. You are giving 3 great guys but he has 2 unbelievable young studs that you are asking for in return. Also I would probably keep Kipnis over Weeks Just based on age

[sigriffey]

Propose it ... if he accepts, it's a big win. I like those two a lot. Reyes is always getting hurt.