Keeper League Trade Options WHIR 100%

[germani40]

Keeper League we can keep up to 15 guys I am getting a lot of offers for Justin Upton it is hard to part with my best young player but if the deal is right you have to take it. All of these offers are on the table.

Deal 1
I get
Utley
Morneau
Luebke
Scott Backer

I give
Upton

Deal 2
get
Moustakas
Dom Brown
Cueto
Norris

I give
Michael Young
Upton

Deal 3
Get
Moustakas
Alex Gordon
Bud Norris

Give
Matt Moore
Upton

Deal 4
Get
Moustakas
Dom Brown
Gordon
Arodys Vizciano

Give
Upton
Moore

Deal 5
Get
Rasmus
Beckett
Anibal Sanchez
Goldschmidt

Give
Vogelsong
Upton



Bold are my projected keepers. If I do any of these deals what players do you think are keeper worthy based on what I already plan on keeping.

C Napoli
1B B. Butler/Ike Davis
2B Uggla/Zobrist
3B M Young/Peralta
SS S Drew/
OF Granderson/Beltran/J Upton/Choo
UTIL Hafner

SP Billingsley/Vogelsong/Haren/Fister/M Moore/Porcello/Colon

RP Madson/Farnsworth/Isringhausen

[wrveres]

Deal 5 is interesting and you could use some power at 1B, but i wouldn't' trade Upton for it.

[fast dogs]

I don't like any of the deals.You have 3 top 50 players, J UP Grand, & Haren probably falls in the 45-50 range. I don't think you bump up your 14-15 spots enuf to take right from the top. You can do much better than whats being offered so far for a young, 2nd rounder. don't trade your prize chip unless you are sure you are coming out ahead, I don't even see these deals as being winners let alone slam dunks

[Philly_05]

Deal 1 and 2 are interesting for different reasons. Deal 1 is a real gamble on Morneau but it could pay off and Utley is a top keeper option at 2B. Deal 2 you get 3 quality young players for 1. You will have to wait for Mous and Dom to get it together but it could payoff down the road big time.

Help on mine?
viewtopic.php?t=436337

[medium_robin]

Upton is the best player in any deal. You want to be GETTING the best player in any deal. I'd say no to all of these.