Rate these two keeper lists... WHIR!

[exm]

Nothing too serious... My brother-in-law and I are in the same league (14 player Yahoo H2H 5pl Keeper) and these are our keepers for next year. He claims his are 'infinitely' better, but I disagree:

His
Pujols, Bautista, Cargo, Pineda, Utley
(2012 est draft round: Pujols #1, Bautista #1, Cargo #2, Pineda #6, Utley #3)

Mine
Cano, Fielder, R Zimmerman, C Lee, Crawford
(2012 est draft round: Cano #1, Fielder #2, Zimm #2, Lee #3, Crawford #3)

Or
Pujols>Fielder
Cano>Utley
Bautista>Zimm
Lee>Pineda
Crawford=Cargo
It's a draw!

He has great players but Utley and Pujols are getting old and Pineda is still unproven. Lee is a top 5 pitcher and Crawford will hopefully rebound next year.

Which team would you prefer and why? "His" or "Mine"? Thanks and WHIR!

[Philly_05]

I would take his easily.

Pujols and Bautista are the best keeper bats both on his team. I personally would rather have Utley but that's a little bias . I would rather have Gonzalez than Crawford. I would also rather have the youth, upside talent of Pineda over Lee who will be on the downside sooner than later.

help on mine?
viewtopic.php?t=436337

[onitapgr]

This is really close.....but I have to go with his team. The deciding factor for me is Crawford vs Cargo....I think Cargo is a much better fantasy player right now.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=436304

[exm]

I would take his easily.

Pujols and Bautista are the best keeper bats both on his team. I personally would rather have Utley but that's a little bias . I would rather have Gonzalez than Crawford. I would also rather have the youth, upside talent of Pineda over Lee who will be on the downside sooner than later.

help on mine?
viewtopic.php?t=436337

You would take Utley over Cano? That's more than a little bias