Keeper league deal. Deadline tonight WHIR 100%

[germani40]

I get
Beckett
Anibel Sanchez
Rasmus
Goldschmidt

Give
Justin upton
Vogelsong

I probably wouldn't be keeping vogelsong this year and will most likely be keeping the 4 guys I get in the deal. Keep up to 15 guys

[ATLbraves]

Yes I definitely like this deal for you, as long as you are planning on keeping all those guys.

[onitapgr]

Upton is so good and so young. He is a top 15 pick, and you are getting 2 10th-rounders and a 2 15th rounders......Without seeing your roster I would pass......If you post your roster (and keepers) I might have a different opinion.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=436304

[germani40]

Roster is in my sig

[Philly_05]

I would keep Upton. To me it really comes down to Upton vs Beckett.

help on mine?
viewtopic.php?t=436337

[onitapgr]

Roster is in my sig

I would pass on this trade. You have 15 good keepers already. The players you would be getting aren't much of an upgrade over any of them. Losing upton is a big deal.

Right now, I would keep

C Napoli
1B B. Butler/Ike Davis
2B Uggla/Zobrist
3B M Young/Peralta
OF Granderson/Beltran/J Upton/Choo

SP Billingsley/Haren/M Moore

RP Madson

[Brainstorm]

i wouldn't for the same reasons others gave. seems like he's throwing a whole bunch of mediocre names to get you to give up a star.

Help please?
viewtopic.php?t=436341