Hamilton For Stanton? First Year Keeper

[kevinbaseballer]

With the downfall of McCann and Weeks my season is all about over. This is our first year keeper league where we keep 4. 10X10 H2H

I am already keeping MCab(1st Pick) Pineada (Last Pick) Josh Johnson (24th pick off waivers)

I was offered Stanton for Hamilton with these 2 choices:

Josh Hamilton 7 Round Pick For Mike Stanton 15th Round Pick
Josh Hamilton 5 Round Pick For Mike Stanton 8th Round Pick

Does either deal make sense long term?
Thanks Will Help In Return

[jruffus1]

Honestly I'd rather have Hamilton in a keeper league, since Stanton still has to prove himself and raise his BA.

[kevinbaseballer]

One thing I neglected keeping Hamilton costs me my 2nd pick while keeping Stanton my 8th pick.

So it would be Stanton 2nd Round Pick and 8th Round Pick For Hamilton 8th,15th Pick

Does that make it more attractive?

[jruffus1]

Yes. In that case, keep Stanton lol.

[bginda2g]

I like Stanton almost equally as much as Hamilton at this point in a keeper league. So with the picks involved, it's Stanton for me.