Wilson and a 9th round pick for David Wright? WHIR 100%

[ATLbraves]

Should I trade my C.J. Wilson and a 9th round pick for David Wright and a 21st? or Beachy and a 10th?

I personally like Beachy's keeper ability more then Wilson's simply because he pitches in a more pitcher friendly division and he can be kept 4 rounds later.

C.J. Wilson can be kept as a 15th round pick next year. Beachy can be kept as a 19th.
David Wright is not keepable.

Some FA SP options are:
Josh Collmenter, Rich Harden (might get traded to the RedSox or Yankees), Freddy Garcia, Paul Maholm, James McDonald, Mike Leake, Gavin Floyd, and Aaron Harang



12 Team H2H. We Keep 6 Players Season to Season for 3 years

Stat Cats: R-HR-RBI-SB-K-TB-AVG-OBP IP-W-L-SV-BB-K-ERA-WHIP
In parentheses are the rounds they can be kept in next season, everyone else wouldn't be keepable imo due to our league rules.

C- Mike Napoli
1B- Miguel Cabrera
2B- Dan Uggla
3B- Pedro Alvarez
SS- Jose Reyes
OF- Chris Young (8th)
OF- Matt Holliday
OF- Drew Stubbs
Util- Michael Morse (7th but could fall if he stops producing)
BN - Travis Snider (15th)
DL - Adrian Beltre


SP- CC Sabathia
Trevor Cahill (13th)
Shaun Marcum
Johnny Cueto (17th)
CJ Wilson (15th)
Bud Norris (13th)
John Danks (13th)
Brandon Beachy (19th)
RP- Brian Wilson
RP-Jose Valverde
RP-Andrew Bailey




WHIR just leave a link

[ABA316]

I'd rather keep Beachy, so trade Wilson of the 2.

What I don't understand though is you said Wright can't be kept. Are you looking to win it all this year, guessing you are there.

Thanks for mine!

[ATLbraves]

Yeah he was a first round pick so you he isn't keepable. With our keeper rules you keep the player 2 rounds ahead of where he was drafted.

And I am in first place so yeah I am trying to win it all this year. I think I have a deep enough pitching staff, and if I get Wright I think it will really help my offense.

[jruffus1]

I actually think you should deal Beachy if you were to make this deal (which I am in favor of). Wilson has more major league experience under his belt and is more consistent overall. Beachy has either been lights out or not that great.

[ABA316]

I'd keep Beachy due to the cost..all other things being equal. Just toss a general thing out to the other guy and see which SP he likes better.

[BronXBombers51]

I agree with keeping Beachy. If Wright will give you a big boost to win it all this year, go for it IMO. Thanks for your help on mine.

[LUISAO]

i will stay put with beachy...besides, beltre is coming back soon, so you have good options

[ATLbraves]

i will stay put with beachy...besides, beltre is coming back soon, so you have good options

Yeah I agree, but I think this move will help put my offense over the top dont you? Lately Stubbs has been striking out a ton and Chris Young has been cold. But I could still start either Young, Stubbs, or Snider based on match-ups in the outfield along with Holliday and Morse. And when Beltre comes back I could start Wright everyday in my UTIL.

[iaoto]

If you are in serious contention I agree with those who say you should get Wright.
Players of Wilson's value can be found easily in drafts next year, you might as well go for the championship.


Thanks for the help on mine!

[ATLbraves]

bump, deal is in place and he has agreed to it. So just want some last minute opinions before I send it. Just to make sure I am making the right move.