Gardner for Norris/Venters or Beachy/Venters?? WHIR

[dans2]

He just sent me two trades... 5x5 Roto non-keep.. I'm back far in Wins.. BUT far far ahead in K's and SV's.. So I'm trying to lower my ERA and WHIP... Heres my team. BEFORE you say anything, I know I have a lot of RP's, but it's kinda gonna be my strategy, as It will lower my ERA and WHIP and I wont be able to be caught in K's and SVs.. (Hopeully I'll own 4 of 5 pitching cats) Good idea?

He offered:

Gardner for:
A. Luebke/Venters
B. Norris/Venters
C. Beachy/ Venters

C: Santana
1: Fielder
2: Prado
SS: Reyes
3: Gordon,
OF: Kemp, McCutchen, Morrison
UTIL: Miguel Cab
B: , Gardner, Ackley, Espinosa

SP: Lincecum, Kershaw, Colon, Dempster, Nolasco, JZimmerman
RP: Marmol, Kimbrel, Walden, Axford, Muljica..

So would you trade Gardner for either of those? and if so: WHICH?

[ATLbraves]

I honestly like Beachy and Venters, but I wouldn't blame you for taking any of the three really.



help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=435572

[dans2]

A braves fan.. is that coming from biased source? haha... You think its a good trade though for me?

[ATLbraves]

A braves fan.. is that coming from biased source? haha... You think its a good trade though for me?

Haha maybe slightly bias'd. But Beachy's numbers dont lie imo. He has amazing K numbers and has a very good ERA. Plus he has the best offense behind him out of all the guys you have listed so he should get you the W's too.

But like I said before, I couldnt blame you for taking any of those trades since Gardner is on your bench and as long as you can risk giving up some SB's.

[TrueNorthChamp]

I like.....A with Leubke. Simply because of that aprk he plays in. All 3 are nice deals however