Chris Perez for Pineda WHIR

[jaysfreak13]

12 team H2H 5X5 I picked up a 5th closer to try and deal one to kind of beef up my SP depth and was offerred this

I'm also trying to trade one of my SS for a SP too before A-Rod comes back

My Roster
C Russell Martin NYY
1B Paul Konerko
2B Dan Uggla ATL
3B/1B Kevin Youkilis BOS
SS J.J Hardy BAL
OF Carl Crawford BOS
OF Michael Bourn HOU
OF Carlos Quentin CHW
UTL/OF Brett Gardner NYY
BN/SS Derek Jeter NYY
DL/3B Alex Rodriguez NYY

SP Shaun Marcum MIL
SP Max Scherzer DET
RP Mark Melancon HOY
RP Chris Perez CLE
P Drew Storen WSH
P Andrew Bailey OAK
P Javy Guerra LAD
BN Kyle Lohse STL
BN Annibal Sanchez FLA
BN Jeremy Helickson TB
BN Johnny Cueto CIN
DL Eric Bedard SEA

What do you think Pineda has been great all year but his last 3 starts worry me a bit

[CubsFan4Life23]

I think it is a close call, but would slightly lean towards keeping Perez as I feel he is a lock for the rest of the year and Pineda could be on a innings limit as well as he has few chances to pick up wins on the Mariners

[RedHopeful]

Not a keeper? Avoid Pineda.

[ATLbraves]

If it's a non-keeper then don't accept this trade, go for another SP who won't be shutdown this season.




help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=435572