Haren/Aybar for Kershaw? WHIR

[mzkp54]

So another team in our league just had Stephen Drew go down, and I just traded my Jurrjens/Bourn for Peralta/Price, so now I have Peralta at SS. I was thinking about offering Haren and Aybar or Peralta for his Kershaw.

Do you think its a worthwhile offer? Should I offer more or less or just avoid it? My team is listed in my sig

His team-
C- Wieters
1B- M Cabrera
2B- G Beckham
3B- Youkilis
SS- J Bartlett
OF- Hamilton, Ellsbury, Gordon
U- G Sanchez, Pagain
B- R Davis, C Rasmus, J Weeks, Crisp

SP- Verlander, Kershaw, Carpenter, Cahill, Ogando, Morrow, Baker, Lilly, Lowe
DL- Bucholz

Thanks for the help, and as always please leave a link.

[ATLbraves]

I think you are giving up too much in both these trades. See if he'll take Weeks, Davis, or Crisp instead.




thanks for the help with mine

[mzkp54]

I think you are giving up too much in both these trades. See if he'll take Weeks, Davis, or Crisp instead.




thanks for the help with mine

You got the teams mixed up. He has Weeks Davis and Crisp. I wanted to try and get Kershaw

[LUISAO]

i dont see that much upgrade at sp to justify giving aybar, plus i dont think the other coach will give away kershaw for an upgrade at SS such as aybar....thanks for the help in mine

[ATLbraves]

I think you are giving up too much in both these trades. See if he'll take Weeks, Davis, or Crisp instead.




thanks for the help with mine

You got the teams mixed up. He has Weeks Davis and Crisp. I wanted to try and get Kershaw

Oh my bad, well I prob wouldnt do the trade then. You are giving up too much. Maybe offer Venters/Haren for Kershaw and see if he bites.

[sigriffey]

I think you are giving up too much in both these trades. See if he'll take Weeks, Davis, or Crisp instead.




thanks for the help with mine

You got the teams mixed up. He has Weeks Davis and Crisp. I wanted to try and get Kershaw

Oh my bad, well I prob wouldnt do the trade then. You are giving up too much. Maybe offer Venters/Haren for Kershaw and see if he bites.

I definitely like Kershaw down the stretch better than traditional second half slouch Haren.

[mzkp54]

I definitely like Kershaw down the stretch better than traditional second half slouch Haren.

You think its worth throwing Aybar in?

[High cheese]

Aybar looks to be having a very good year by his standards. That being said, I'd rather have Kershaw

[TrueNorthChamp]

Kershaw side all day long in this one.

[theblemishedone]

Throw Aybar in, especially if he's taking up your bench.

This is strictly my opinion, but I feel the bench is best reserved for top tier players. It's way too tough to try and stream batters and predict who will do what.

No knock on Aybar and Haren, but I'd rather have Kershaw down the stretch.

I definitely like Kershaw down the stretch better than traditional second half slouch Haren.

You think its worth throwing Aybar in?