Young/Miggy for Beltran/Beckett/Youk?

[redskincow]

My new offer is beltran/beckett/youk FOR Chris Young & Miggy...

Good deal? or other suggestions. It will have to be a 2 for 1 or 3 for 2 deal...

His current offer to me is Weaver & Youk for Miggy....

12 team H2H keep 2 (K=can keep)
Pts-based:
Batting (1pt/Single, 2pt/Double, 3pt/Triple, 4pt/HR, -1/K,+1/SB, -1/CS, +1/BB, 1pt/RBI or Run)
Pitching (.5pt/Inn, 1pt/K, -1/ER, 10pt/W, 10pt/SO, -5/Loss, 5pt/Save, -2/BS)

C) Montero
1B) Hosmer (K)
2B) Prado
3B) Youkilis
SS) Barney (K)
MI) Ackley (K)
CI) R Zimmerman
OF) Beltran
OF) Ellsbury
OF) Bruce
OF) Kemp
OF) M Morse (K)
UTIL) Napoli
Bench) D Jennings (K)
Bench) Wigginton (K)
Bench) Aubrey Huff
Bench) Casey McGehee
SP) Jurrjens (K)
SP) Weaver
SP) Beckett
SP) Hanson (K)
SP) Greinke
Bench) Pineda (K)
Bench) G Gonzalez

[High cheese]

I like this deal, especially if you can keep Cabrera, since you can afford the loss at SP. Although I'd probably try Grienke or Gonzalez and Youkalis first.

[redskincow]

yeah youk and gonzalez won't fly...thanks though

can't keep Miggy...Keepers are drafted 18th round or undrafted WW adds...unless you've kept someone for multiple years...my current keepers are Hanson and Hosmer

[redskincow]

How would you value Ryan Zimmeman instead of Youk in the deal? better/worse

[guyincognito]

I would do that. As for Zimm vs Youk, if I were the Miggy owner, I'd probably want Youk over Zimm. But this would certainly be a good deal for you since you can afford to take the hit at SP. Thanks for the help on mine.

[ATLbraves]

How would you value Ryan Zimmeman instead of Youk in the deal? better/worse

I would much rather give up Zimmerman then Youk, but either way I think this is a great deal for you. Chris Young is a 5-cat fantasy OF'er and Miggy is well... Miggy, one of the best hitters in MLB.

[redskincow]

then would you give up Weaver and Youk for Miggy?

[ATLbraves]

then would you give up Weaver and Youk for Miggy?

Thats a hard once to accept honestly, will he not take Gio and Youk for Miggy? That would be a much better trade for you.

[MadDog36]

Chris Young & Miggy