KEEPER TRADE *WHIR*

[michaelyoung4prez]

Really on the fence about this trade. If I do it the biggest problem is I would no longer be able to keep Felix next year because he is kept as a 2nd round pick, which I am trading away. I would move Panda to 3rd and insert Howard at 1B. I believe there is enough talent on waivers to replace Gardner.

My:
Aramis
Daniel Hudson
Brett Gardner
Round 2 pick 2011
Round 6 pick 2011

for

Ryan Howard
Verlander
Round 13 pick 2011
Round 14 pick 2011



12 Team H2H
C-Santana
1B-Panda
2B-Kinsler
3B-Aramis
SS-Tulo
OF-Gardner
OF-McCutchen
OF-Hamilton
UTIL-Pena
BN-L.Morrison
SP-Felix
SP-Gallardo
SP-D Hudson
RP-None
BN-Bummgarner
BN-Ervin Santana
BN-B. Norris
BN-Dempster
DL-Danks

[Mateo de Lorenzo]

Really on the fence about this trade. If I do it the biggest problem is I would no longer be able to keep Felix next year because he is kept as a 2nd round pick, which I am trading away. I would move Panda to 3rd and insert Howard at 1B. I believe there is enough talent on waivers to replace Gardner.

My:
Aramis
Daniel Hudson
Brett Gardner
Round 2 pick 2011
Round 6 pick 2011

for

Ryan Howard
Verlander
Round 13 pick 2011
Round 14 pick 2011



12 Team H2H
C-Santana
1B-Panda
2B-Kinsler
3B-Aramis
SS-Tulo
OF-Gardner
OF-McCutchen
OF-Hamilton
UTIL-Pena
BN-L.Morrison
SP-Felix
SP-Gallardo
SP-D Hudson
RP-None
BN-Bummgarner
BN-Ervin Santana
BN-B. Norris
BN-Dempster
DL-Danks

I am not very experience3d with value for draft picks, but it seems like you are giving up a little too much. I would either counter with giving up a third round instead of the second, or get a little better return in the draft picks you receive from him.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=435226

[ATLbraves]

I agree I dont like the idea of you having to give up a 2nd and 6th. I would see if he will take a 4th and 6th and if not, MAYBE a 3rd and 6th but that is still asking for a lot imo.

If he insists on receiving a 3rd and 6th then ask for better picks in return.




help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=435220