Vmart or McCann?

[hockeykidb3]

So I am in a non-keeper head to head categories league, and I am about to trade a catcher. I don't know who to keep and who to trade. I had Vmart and just got McCann. Trust me when I say keeping both of them is not an option. McCann has higher power numbers, Vmart has a better average. What concerns me about McCann is he does not play everyday. When Vmart is not catching he is a DH and plays everyday. McCann being in the NL cannot do that. So who should I keep?

[kaiser]

Short term, I like VMart for the remainder of the season. From a keeper perspective, I'd take McCann, by just a little bit.