Pineda/Hanson for Pujols? WHIR

[Kegglers]

Yahoo 10 team league. We keep 3 players. Might bump to 4 into next season. Doesn't really matter in this as I have no intention of keeping Pineda or Hanson next year.


Scoring is Yahoo with these categories. (yes, crazy, I know)

Hitting>>>AB-R-H-1B-2B-3B-HR-RBI-SF-SB-BB-TB-AVG-OBP-SLG

Pitching>>>IP-APP-W-L-CG-SHO-SV-ER-K-HLD-ERA-WHIP-K/BB-K/9-QS


I have been offered

Albert Pujols 1B Stl

for my

Michael Pineda SP Sea

and

Tommy Hanson SP Atl


Here is my starting lineup for reference. Yes, we start 2 at each position.


C Chris Iannetta
C Jorge Posada
1B Adrian Gonzalez
1B Eric Hosmer
2B Howie Kendrick
2B Dustin Ackley
3B Mike Moustakas
3B Pedro Alvarez
SS Starlin Castro
SS Hanley Ramirez
OF Jacoby Ellsbury
F Grady Sizemore
OF Carlos Beltran
OF Ryan Braun
Util Adam Jones
Util Casey Kotchman
DL Alex Rodriguez
DL Chipper Jones
DL Shin-Soo Choo
DL Brian Roberts

SP Hanson, Pineda, Greinke, Gallardo, Bumgarner, Cain, Liriano, Zimmerman
RP Bailey, Walden, Nathan, Clippard, Venters, Crow





Thanks for any comments in advance. Leave a link and I'll be happy to reply to yours.

[ahcryky]

If you can get Pujols for that, especially if you aren't even considering keeping the players you are trading away you do it......... If this was proposed to you, do it now before the other team changes their mind. If you are thinking about proposing this, I don't see this getting accepted.

[Kegglers]

If you can get Pujols for that, especially if you aren't even considering keeping the players you are trading away you do it......... If this was proposed to you, do it now before the other team changes their mind. If you are thinking about proposing this, I don't see this getting accepted.

Yeah, trade was proposed to me. All I gotta do is hit the ole accept button....

[ensanimal]

Hit the accept button as quick as you can. Pujols is still one of the top keepers in the league and you use enough positions that having top 1B doesn't really matter.

[mpieco]

I'd be interested in knowing the following:

Who are your 3 (and also 4) keepers BEFORE this trade?

Who are your 3 (and also 4) keepers AFTER this trade?

Just curious.

[Kegglers]

I'd be interested in knowing the following:

Who are your 3 (and also 4) keepers BEFORE this trade?

Who are your 3 (and also 4) keepers AFTER this trade?

Just curious.

Good question!!



3 keepers BEFORE trade are Braun, Hanley, A. Gonzalez
3 keepers AFTER trade would be Braun, A. Gonz, and I'd prob flip a coin between Pujols and Hanley


4 keepers BEFORE trade would be Braun, Hanley, A. Gonz, A-Rod
4 keepers AFTER trade would be Braun, Hanley, A. Gonz, Pujols


I think either way, I'm looking good for keepers. Though, I'd be looking a bit better if we go to 4 keepers AND I do this trade.

[theblemishedone]

Do the trade and run as fast as you can.

[High cheese]

2 non keepers for the best one of best 3 hitters in baseball? No brainer indeed

[kidsilk]

This is a no brainer man. Pull the trigger and keep Pujols over Hanley.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=435159

[mpieco]

Since you have no plans for holding on to Hanson, then this deal is a no-brainer.