Am I Giving Too Much for Miggy

[mpieco]

In my mind, Walker is worth Barney/Lewis together. I'm very high on Neil Walker...he's like a poor man's Robinson Cano.

So, the deal is essentially Miggy/Nolasco for Fielder/Lester.

I'd say that you're giving up a bit too much in the starting pitching category for what isn't much of an upgrade (some would even consider it a downgrade). I'd either look to try and get back something a bit better than Nolasco. Although, I'd rather have Kershaw and Lee, so if you have to give up one of your 3 stud pitchers, Lester is the right one.

[dannahann]

Miggy is only year older than fielder. Plus isn't fielders weight and poor defense a concern. What if he ends up being a dh like David Ortiz.

Prince isn't a poorer defender than Miggy and a year and a half ago a guy in our league dealt Miggy due to concerns over HIS ballooning weight gain? Miggy is more likely to become a dh than Prince IMO, mainly because Miggy is a for sure AL guy and on a team with an aging DH to boot. If we're going to play the what if game, what if Miggy gets arrested driving drunk once again or gets swallowed up by his alcohol problems? Prince + Lester is too much in most of our opinions.

[High cheese]

If Prince hits the way he's had all year than he could be 300lbs for all I care. Cabrera is no Weight Watcher spokesman himself. Lester is the dealer breaker for sure