Am I Giving Too Much for Miggy

[rasto21585]

Just got offered miggy neil walker and ricky nolaco for my fielder lester colby lewis and darwin barney. Am I giving too much here or is this deal I must accept ASAP. Team is below.



20 team h2h dynasty league

c j.p. arencibia
1b prince fielder
2b robinson cano
3b evan longoria
ss yunel escobar
inf zack cozart
lf cody ross
cf colby rasmus
rf justin upton
of peter bourjos
util ryan theriot
bn jerry sands
bn darwin barney
dl jose tabata



sp clayton kershaw
sp jon lester
sp bud norris
sp cliff lee
rp jason motte
rp javy guerra
ry matt guerir
p aaron harang
p jason ingrnhausen
p scott downs
bn colby lewis
bn jason hammel
bn matt harrisson
dl rafael soriano

[rasto21585]

bump please

[dannahann]

In your setup (20T dynasty) he's asking for too much. I'd pass.

[rasto21585]

Honestly I don't care too much for colby lewis and darwin barney. So what makes you think this is too much?

[dannahann]

Honestly I don't care too much for colby lewis and darwin barney. So what makes you think this is too much?

I kind of agree on Lewis and Barney. To me they are about as valuable as his Nolasco and Walker. I like Walker over barney by avout as much as I like Lewis over Nolasco. I really see the trade as essentially Miggy for Fielder and Lester and I wouldn't trade your two studs for his one in a 20 team dynasty. If you think the Walker Nolasco package trumps Lewis and Barney by enough go for it. I simply don't think there is enough gap to justify trading both Lester and Prince.

[rasto21585]

what if i trade matt harrison instead of colby lewis? Is that better?

[rasto21585]

Btw if I do this trade, I was thinking of dealing cano and rasmus for felix and mccutchen. Do these 2 trades make my team better overall?

[DLRBusiness]

i'd rather have fielder than miggy, especially in a keeper. and lester is a top 15 pitcher.

[ahcryky]

Fielder is beginning his prime...... In that deep of a dynasty, I would pass.

[rasto21585]

Miggy is only year older than fielder. Plus isn't fielders weight and poor defense a concern. What if he ends up being a dh like David Ortiz.