Question

[Guest]

Edgar Renteria, Lance Berkman, and Sean Burroughs
for
Eric Chavez, Vernon Wells, and Placido Polanco

please just give me your input. should this be overthrown?

[hi]

BUMP???? i need help fast. there is a problem in my $$ league

[Cornbread Maxwell]

Vetoed?

absolutely not.

no trade is going to be 100% even, and at least these owners are trying to keep it close.

No way should this be vetoed.

[Rick007]

I don't think it should be vetoed.

[TrappedInBristol]

IMO, this is not anywhere close to a value-for-value trade. The trio of Chavez, Wells, and Polanco is a big upgrade over Renteria, Berkman, and Burroughs.

That being said, I believe in the priciple of "let the buyer beware".

No veto, sez I!

[Cornbread Maxwell]

IMO, this is not anywhere close to a value-for-value trade. The trio of Chavez, Wells, and Polanco is a big upgrade over Renteria, Berkman, and Burroughs.

That being said, I believe in the priciple of "let the buyer beware".

No veto, sez I!

lol - I am exactly the opposite. Id rather have the renteria side.

Chavez is overrated - as is Polanco. Is Polanco even fantasy worthy now that we know he will have 0 protection in PHI?

The main point is that this is close enough to argue, therefore it should go through.

[afromangettindrunk]

veto it.























just kidding

[bump]

bump

[matmat]

why bump again?

there is no way this should be vetoed. it isn't even clear which side is getting the better deal. A veto is not a tool for you to use when you think someone is improving their team enough to beat you.

[Sevillano]

If I was an owner involved in this trade and it was vetoed by the commish this early in the season, I would quit the league before anymore of time was wasted.