Who Wins This Trade?

[rasto21585]

In a 20 team h2h dynasty league, who wins this trade?

team a get miggy lincecum neil walker

team b get fielder cano bud norris

[dkatt3]

really could go either way, but i would take team A. Miggy's the most consistent fantasy player, and lincecum is always going to be solid, but who knows where prince will play next year and he displays inconsistency... and i like walker over norris. Can you help me?
viewtopic.php?t=435041

[MaudDib]

Yep I will take Walkers side but really a pretty even trade either way.

[MadDog36]

I'd rather have the two stud bats and an up and coming ace in Norris personally.
fielder cano bud norris

[High cheese]

Trade is pretty even but I like Fielder/Cano combo a bit better.

[dannahann]

Trade is pretty even but I like Fielder/Cano combo a bit better.

Even though Miggy is the best of the bunch I agree with this. Prince isn't that far back and Cano is less risky than is Lincecum.

[mpieco]

I'm taking Fielder/Cano/Norris, and I'll explain why.

I'm getting the BEST player at a VERY difficult position to fill (Cano). That's my reason.

I cannot say the same about Miggy. He might not be the best player at his position, and his position is not the hardest to fill. Just look at all the mid-tier talent out there this year putting up nice numbers (Lind, Freeman, Trumbo).

Lincecum for Norris is obviously a step down, but you're paying for the improvement from Walker to Cano. SP is easier to come by then 2B, and Norris is going to K almost as much as Lincecum anyway, so you're getting back one of the cats you lost at least. He's going to be a Fantasy #2 someday, and an ace for the Astros.