Big keeper league trade, please help

[dkatt3]

I give: Miguel Cabrera, Jay Bruce, Pablo Sandoval

I get: Carlos Gonzalez, Tim Lincecum, Hunter Pence, Joel Hanrahan



8 team h2h categories, and we keep 3 players. My best players are miguel, hanley, and kershaw/hanson, so i dont have a good keeper option after my top 2 which is why I am reluctant to lose one of them.... some other guys on my team are mike stanton, shane victorino, lester, mauer, aramis, mariano rivera, huston street, bwilson... Thanks

[bears2]

You are not valueing panda very high if this trade is the case..Here is my take or pros and cons..

lincecum -not much run support and leaving him in for 120+ pitches too many times i feel will catch up to him
cargo-bad wrist you could be getting a player on the dl any day
hanrahan - talk is he may be traded by tarde deadline and wont be a closer
hunter pence- he is a good player but not that good

Miggy-too good to trade for anything other than a top healthy player
Panda- has been killing the ball
bruce- my opinion not very good but his value is low so why give him away.

so in final analysis your tradeding 2 superstars in miggy an panda for a few guys playing solid but question marks in the future..I would not do this..You need top dollar healthy players for miggy an panda.

[MadDog36]

Don't overvalue Kung Fu Panda, but at the same time don't undervalue what he's getting. That being said....

With you having Wilson, Street, Little Mo at closer that is good enough.
kershaw, hanson, lester lead your rotation, no need for lincy
miggy cab stanton hanley and panda are your 3 best offensive keepers

so you have SS and 3b covered well this year a big bopping 1b 2 quality OF in Vic and Stanton. Eh your set bud, no need to trade here.

What I'd do is package Aramis+Victorino for a stud OF is what I'd do. If Stanton is your best OF that would be in need of an upgrade IMO for an 8 teamer.

[redskincow]

Don't overvalue Kung Fu Panda, but at the same time don't undervalue what he's getting. That being said....

With you having Wilson, Street, Little Mo at closer that is good enough.
kershaw, hanson, lester lead your rotation, no need for lincy
miggy cab stanton hanley and panda are your 3 best offensive keepers

so you have SS and 3b covered well this year a big bopping 1b 2 quality OF in Vic and Stanton. Eh your set bud, no need to trade here.

What I'd do is package Aramis+Victorino for a stud OF is what I'd do. If Stanton is your best OF that would be in need of an upgrade IMO for an 8 teamer.

Amen...don't trade miggy. You can find or trade for OF much more easily than you can replace miggy.