which trade would u rather???? WHIR

[ratking20]

my zimmerman 3b for his j.garcia sp
or my youkilis for his sabathia

i currently have zimmerman, youkilis, g.sanchez, and votto
youk starts at 3b, votto at 1b, and right now g.sanchez at dh

i cant start all 4, the team with arod going down has cain, sabathia and j.garcia
he needs a 3b and wants to work something out

h2h standard points league
im in first at 11-3 in my division

my pitchers: j.weaver, c. lee, jurjjens, b.norris, scherzer, a.sanchez, liriano, bumgarner, j.sancez

[MadDog36]

Keep Youk. Too expensive there.
Deal Zimm for Garcia if that's the best you can do. Zimm's kinda not producing very much.
Can you not do any better than that though?

[ratking20]

pitching is huge in this league, its tough for anyone to give up a god pitcher

[High cheese]

Either scenario I'd rather have Sabathia

[akotin]

the sabathia trade for sure.

viewtopic.php?t=435077

[mpieco]

You might be "giving up too much" to get Sabathia, but that's not necessarily the right way to look at a trade.

No matter what one of those four has to ride the bench right now, so why not use one of them to get a top 3 pitcher? Zimmerman slides into the 3B slot, and he's bound to start performing soon--he has a highly productive history.