is this a fair trade?

[moosehockey20]

Team A Sends:
Mccutchen

Team B Sends:
Felix Hernandez


Or

Team A Sends:
Mccutchen
Beachy
Karstens

Team B Sends:
Felix Hernandez

[whitheadsuxs]

show me your roster tell me your league type and ill be glad to help you on the surface i rather always have a bat than a pitch

[hockeykidb3]

C Joe Mauer, Min C, DH
1B Albert Pujols, StL 1B
2B Chase Utley, Phi 2B
3B Pablo Sandoval, SF 3B S
SS Hanley Ramirez, Fla SS
2B/SS Brandon Phillips, Cin 2B
1B/3B Kevin Youkilis, Bos 1B, 3B
OF Jacoby Ellsbury, Bos OF
OF Andrew McCutchen, Pit OF
OF Michael Morse, Was OF, 1B
OF Jay Bruce, Cin OF
OF Hunter Pence, Hou OF
DH Adam Lind, Tor DH, 1B
UTIL David Ortiz, Bos DH
Bench Ryan Braun, Mil OF DTD
DL Jose Reyes*, NYM SS DL15
P Roy Halladay, Phi SP
P Ubaldo Jimenez, Col SP
P Joel Hanrahan, Pit RP
P Cliff Lee, Phi SP
P David Price, TB SP
P Leo Nunez, Fla RP
P Brandon Beachy, Atl SP
P Jason Vargas, Sea SP
P Philip Humber, CWS RP, SP
Bench Andrew Miller, Bos SP
Bench Jeff Karstens, Pit SP DTD
DL J.J. Putz*, Ari RP DL15

I am in his league, this is his roster. It is a head to head non keeper categories league with 8 pitching categories and 7 hitting categories. I thought the trade was unfair because both of the pitchers he is trading for Felix he has picked up out of free agency in the past couple days. Karstens has only beaten 2 teams over .500, one of which was the Red Sox when Ortiz wasn't in the lineup and Crawford was on the DL. Also Beachy has not beat a team over .500 this year. McCutchen is higher on player rater but Felix is ranked 2nd on 60' 6", where McCutchen is ranked 20 on Hit Parade.

[Guido_BagDonnavich]

I think McCutchen for Felix is a pretty fair trade.

[MadDog36]

Team A Sends:
Mccutchen

Team B Sends:
Felix Hernandez

[moosehockey20]

is that what you would do. i think that is fair too

[moosehockey20]

i ended up trading mccutchen, putz/ felix hernandez

[whitheadsuxs]

you clearly have a ton of bats so thats not gonna end up killing you looks like a pretty good trade to me