Votto for Lee?

[tommo]

I'm just still not sure if I win here. Hoping for more advice. I'd lose Votto for Lee with either Butler, Hosmer, Morse, Moreland, Trumbo, or Freeman being his replacement. I'm not sure if the difference between Lee and whichever pitcher I replace makes up for the drop-off between Votto and any of these options at first. I could also try to move Marcum for Lind which would be a better replacement than any of the aforementioned.

[tommo]

Would Bautista for Halladay be a better move for me?

[tailgate13]

I tried to pull off the same deal in my 16 team keeper league, but the guy with Votto did not go through with the deal because he did not beleive he could replace a bat like that in the draft, but believes you can ride some hot pitchers year to year. I have had lee for 3 seasons and have not been able to move him for a legit keeper bat. I think it's a fair deal, but managers in my league don't have the same point of view(for what its worth)

[tommo]

Neither of them would be keeper eligible but thank you for the input.

[tailgate13]

would you mind taking a look at my post in the same forum: Lots of prospects on my keeper league roster? thx