dannahann wrote:In a vacuum either deal is very good to get a stud like Prince. Given your roster I don't like either. Oswalt's back is acting up again and your starting pitching was thin to begin with so you don't really have the pitching to do deal 1. The Youk trade is also good but not for your lineup. You really need to find a way to retain Youk and play him at 3B while also getting Prince. Assuming he was willing to take deal 1, is there any chance he'd bite if you replaced one of the SP (preferably Pineda) with another bat? Losing Carlos Lee or CB Young wouldn't hurt you at all if you were adding prince.
I forgot to mention this is a dynasty league. Sorry about that.
That being said, like I said in my original post, I would keep that short and to the point. Well, here are the details, for specifics.
The Youk/mid reliever for Fielder is pretty straight forward.
The other trade scenario is more complicated.
it is actually Bumgarner/Pineida/Davis for A-Rod/Scott Downs and then A-rod/Scott Downs for Fielder. So in essence is Bum/Pine/Ike for Fielder, like I put.
The manager with Fielder has Matt Cain I would try to include some how, but I don't have much faith in the Giants giving him run rupport.
The manager with A-Rod has Halladay who he is also trying to move for players to play in the future. Not sure if I could package enough to get him to trade Halladay too. Or, would it be better for me to focus on Halladay with prospects and then try to land the Youk for Fielder?
Thanks for the input. This is my first dynasty league and I dont want to do anything stupid.