Do this trade?

[The305MiamiCanes]

A guy who has just taken over a team in my league offered me Kinsler/Halladay/Gardner for my Longoria/CC
Thoughts? Its my 2nd team in the sig.

His team
C-Mauer
1B-Cabrera
2B-Kinsler
3B-Ian Stewart
SS-Escobar
OF-Pence, Markakis, Gardner
UT-Pagan, Rajai
BN-Raburn, Ibanez, Napoli
SP-Halladay, Verlander, Liriano, Colby Lewis, Lackey, Scherzer
RP-Feliz, Venters, Soriano, Clippard

My team
C-Avilla
1B-Howard, Hosmer
2B-Ryan Roberts
3B-Longoria, Moustakas
SS-Hanley, Desmond
OF-Crawford, Bruce, Ellsbury, Francoeur, Joyce
SP-Sabathia, Lester, Price, Felix, Morrow, Pineda, Vogelsong
RP-Hanrahan, Sergio Santos, Salas, Frank Francisco

[ahcryky]

Trade's pretty much blah for me. It would be nice to have Halladay, but I would much rather have Longoria over Kinsler. And him throwing in Gardner means absolutely nothing to me, You already have a crowded OF.

[The305MiamiCanes]

What should I counter with then? I really want Halladay

[ahcryky]

Don't bankrupt your team to get a pitcher. Your starting pitching staff is already strong. You should be looking more to upgrade 2B and maybe find a RP to replace Santos, Salas, and Francisco. And the other teams 2B being Kinsler isn't someone I would be targeting unless I could buy really low.

[High cheese]

Your starters are pretty strong so even though you have a "thing" for Halladay I wouldn't make this deal. I'd much rather have Longo and CC