Longoria for Howard?

[Alkaholik]

10 team h2h league.

i was offered my
Evan Longoria, 3B - TB

for his:
Ryan Howard, 1B - PHI

now this doesnt make much sense since i already have fielder and gaby sanchez, but what if i move Pablo sanduval at 3b, move howard to my util and then trade away gaby sanchez?

which would you prefer.

Scenario 1:
1b: Prince Fielder, 1b - MIL
3b: Evan Longoria, 3b - TB
Util: Gaby Sanchez, 1b - FLA
BN: Pablo Sanduval, 1b/3b - SF

Scenario 2:
1b: Prince Fielder, 1b - MIL
3b: Pablo Sanduval, 1b/3b - SF
Util: Ryan Howard, 1b - PHI
BN: Gaby Sanchez, 1b - FLA

[MaudDib]

Not a chance. Longoria is a top 10 overall player and you should only expect that kind of player in return. Howard is a solid 1B but you have no need for him and he just isn't the guy he used to be.

[avsfan4ever33]

Not a chance. Longoria is a top 10 overall player and you should only expect that kind of player in return. Howard is a solid 1B but you have no need for him and he just isn't the guy he used to be.

Yep. I know Longo has been disappointing so far this season, but I fully expect him to heat up in the second half.

[wazzeus]

Longoria might very well disappoint all year, and there's no doubt Howard will put up better numbers, but 3B is such a thin position that Longo is still the more valuable of the two.