Trade for Stubbs, what's fair?

[saemick]

Guy needs SP BAD and willing to part with Stubbs. Which SP(s) would be a fair trade:

12-team 6x6 H2H Yahoo! NON-KEEPER league

SP: Verlander, Scherzer, Hellickson, Pineda, Jurrjens, Zimmerman, Bumgarner, Liriano
Pitchers: W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, QS

I think I can get him for one of: Scherzer, Jurrjens, or Pineda straight up.

which of those 3 would make the most sense for me to trade away?

Thanks

[ahcryky]

Well, if that manager would give up Stubbs for any of those starters he's desperate. If I owned Stubbs and it was a 1 for 1 deal the only pitcher that I would even consider trading him for would be Verlander, and even that wouldn't do it for me. Any of those pitchers you are saying he would take I would love to unload Scherzer.

[sigriffey]

Package Scherzer with bumgarner ... I actually wouldn't do it he asked for verlander... I think aces like Verlander don't grow in trees, and while neither does Stubbs, I'd much rather see you shed quantity than quality to get him if u can.

[Millhouse]

Keep Verlander...see if he'll accept a package of two of Bum/Zimmerman/Pineda for Stubbs (Pineda will be capped soon, sell high). Or if he wants to go up to Scherzer, I'd do that too.

See mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=433631