Best Stud Ace Trade Offer WHIR

[EdKoch]

I have already negotiated Braun for Haren OR Hamilton/Vogelsong for King Felix. I have not pressed the button yet.

This offer came today... Bautista and Hardy have been untouchable. Plus, I think I found a steal in Espinosa. Please help.

WHIR WHIR WHIR WHIR WHIR WHIR

League: 12 team, 5x5 weekly with daily changes, R-HR-RBI-SB-OPS vs W-SV-K-ERA-WHIP, Both leagues, Yahoo

I GET:
Kinsler
Marcum
Correia
Holland

HE GETS:
D. Espinosa
Hardy
Bautista
Vogelsong

MY TEAM:
C Posada
1B Konerko
2B Espinosa
SS Hardy
3B Bautista
OF Hamilton
OF Brantley
OF Joyce
DH Braun
DH Granderson

BN: Peralta
BN: Moustakas
BN: Rizzo
BN: Choo
DL: B. Roberts

SP: Weaver
SP: Ogando
SP: Hanson
SP: Vogelsong
SP: Cueto
SP: Villanueva
SP: Garza
SP: C. Lewis

RP: Cordero
RP: Walden
RP: Romo

DL: SP: McClellan

HIS TEAM:
C Montero
1B M. Cabrera
2B Kinsler
SS Desmond
3B Zimmerman
OF Ichiro
OF Ellsbury
OF N. Cruz
DH B. Phillips
DH Huff

BN: Pagan
BN: Napoli
DL: Freese

SP: Marcum
SP: Pineda
SP: Correia
SP: Holland
SP: J. Garcia (STL)
SP: Masterson
SP: Matusz

RP: Wilson
RP: Farnsworth
RP: Clippard
RP: Marshall

DL: SP: Santana

[avsfan4ever33]

First off, don't deal Braun for Haren. That would be a very bad deal for you. I also wouldn't do Hammy/Vogelsong for Felix, though that's at least a closer deal.

To the main deal you asked about - I'd also pass on this one. Bautista is easily the most valuable player in the trade, and though the other three players you'd be giving up aren't exactly studs, I don't think the return is enough. Kinsler is good, but always an injury risk; Marcum is very solid but was injured tonight (not sure how serious it is); Correia and Holland are fairly mediocre SP options.

[etl1692]

I have to agree... With the big trade Bautista is just a beast! I dont see a good return for him. Some quality players but no real STUD.... I'd Hang on. You can get more!

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=433608

[KingOfSports]

Correia and Holland are barely decent imo. They are just throw-in players. You can get more for Bautista.

[rjforlife]

None of the trades in your post are even close to good trades. You need to start fresh because they aren't even close. Back to the drawing board my son....

[Millhouse]

PASS
PASS
PASS

You're getting *abused* for Bautista in that deal.

Did I say PASS?

See mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=433631