Trade: My shields/Quentin for Jurrjens/Marcum WHIR

[jlfn56]

I give up shields and Carlos quentin and recieve Jair jurrjens and Shaun Marcum

Who wins?

My Team

Vmart
AGON
Uggla
Sandoval
Reyes
Granderson
Ethier
Quentin
Joyce Util
Konerko Util
Sizemore Bench
DL David Wright

Halladay
Lester
Chacin
Gio Gonzo
James Shields
Buchholz
Ogando
and some closers

[ahcryky]

I'd pass on that, your OF can't take the hit of the loss of Quentin.

[baseballstud]

i agree, losing quentin for a starter isn't gonna do much good for you right now. your staff is already very strong.


help me?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=433450

[MaudDib]

Nope. Your 2 players have more upside then the other 2 guys. Plus you need the OF help more than you need the extra SP.