Must Cut 1: Soria, Madson or Salas? WHIR

[Trebor]

Ive tried trading, but small roster league and everyone already has their 2 closers. I need some OF help as both Rajai and D.Brown are stinking it up. thinking about D.Ackley (need a 2B backup as well). I held out for waaaay too long with 3 RPs, we can only ever start 2 (unless they are SP elig), and with no trade in future, its time I cut 1 of them...almost silly ive gone this long with 3 (was waiting to see if Soria could right the ship)


who would YOU cut: J.Soria, R.Madson or F.Salas???


Pitch cats: W-L-S-CG-SHO-BB-K-ERA-WHIP

with Wandy now active, I must drop TWO PLAYERS in order to make an OF pickup. I was figuring D.Brown given his struggles was def 1...I need Rajais SBs. Im projected to hit moves max early, so this must move stick...I cant go re-picking up the closer I drop. I appreciate any and all help

WHIR



********************************************************

ROSTER and LEAGUE SPECS

12 team H2H
3rd yr of 4 yr Keeper (only best 1-3 players kept/yr)
19 Cats, 18 roster spots + 2 DL
Bat: r-1b-2b-3b-hr-rbi-sb-bb-k-avg
Pitch: w-l-s-cg-sho-bb-k-era-whip
24/45 Moves used

C- M.Montero
1B- Votto
2B- N.Walker 2B/3B
3B- R.Zimmerman
SS- Alexei Ramirez
OF- J.Hamilton
OF- J.Bruce
OF- Rajai Davis
U- Konerko

Bench1- Domonic Brown OF
Bench2- J.Peralta 3B/SS

DL1- B.Anderson SP
DL2- W.Rodriguez SP

SP- Verlander
SP- Scherzer
RP- Salas
P- (2nd closer) R.Madson
Bench3- J.Zimmermann*
Bench4- I.Kennedy*
Bench5- J.Soria RP

*17 IP min per week, so bench SPs rotated in when needed

[Trebor]

morning after BUMP

WHIR

[Cypher74]

All those guys have value, you can't trade one?

If you are maxxing out on moves, and this is truly for the rest of the season, I'd deal Madson as Lidge will be back soon. But in the short term, I'd actually ditch Soria before the other two.

Help if you can?

viewtopic.php?t=433464

[Trebor]

No, i cant make any deals.

no trades. ive tried.

im asking about CUTTING.

thx and WHIR

[fast dogs]

hasn't Brown had 3 HR this week? I don't see the need to have backups on the roster in small leagues, just use the FA list as your bench

[etl1692]

This is tough I wouldnt wanna ddrop one but if u have to im thinking....... Salas

viewtopic.php?t=433480

[jaysfreak13]

If you have to drop one out of those 3 the answer is easily Salas

Soria has his closing job back and Madson has been solid and is still closing even after Contreras came back.