Votto/Prince/Agone for Reyes?

[Mr November]

So I'm in a roto keeper league and have been fortunate enough through out the years to accumulate the triumvirate of Votto/Prince/Agone. I start one at 1B and the other 2 at UTIL. I have an offer for any of the 3 for Reyes and my current SS is Alex Gonzalez. Do I stand pat because I have 3 studs or better my team with Reyes? I'm always nervous with Reyes because of injuries and such. Thoughts?!

[DattKemp27]

How is your team doing in steals, you could probably benifit from Reyes if your behind in it and hes just been unstopable so far, but i would have a tough time chosing which one of those to trade.

[bloul11]

If you set on trading I would go with Agone. I think I might just stay put though unless you are desperate for SB.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=433333

[ahcryky]

I'd trade Fielder..........

[ATLbraves]

I really dont think I could trade any of those guys for Reyes straight up. He cant give you a 2 for 1? Maybe throw in a pitcher or something too and make it a fair deal.

[baegames]

I would offer Fielder; wouldn't even think of the other two (Votto would be my second choice). And make it a 2-for-1 where you get an upgrade elsewhere because Reyes is not as valuable as Fielder, but it's close.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=433188

[DattKemp27]

I really dont think I could trade any of those guys for Reyes straight up. He cant give you a 2 for 1? Maybe throw in a pitcher or something too and make it a fair deal.

I agree with this, mabye you could try and push a decent starter out of him, if he really needs power he will probably accept it.

[IzzyDavis]

i really think it all depends on what your needs are. If you dominate hr/rbi and lack runs/sb make the trade. But you should insist on a 2 for 1 as already said. Reyes already isnt as valuable as any of those 3 and given his injury histroy his is even more of a long term risk. As for which one to trade id go with Prince.