Drop Peralta for Roberts? Need 3B..WAHIR

[BiGAnT]

I drafted Casey McGehee and we all know how that turned out (and he's been long dropped)...I picked up Peralta a few weeks ago and he's been pretty good lately, but Ryan Roberts was just dropped and I figure he might be a better fit the rest of the year (especially seeing as he can steal a few bags here and there, where as Peralta does not really have that ability). Roberts also has a little more power than Peralta but Peralta will probably have more RBIs since he is batting 7 for the Tugers, rather than first for the DBacks but again I'm not sure which 3B to go with here...also I could try trading for a 3B instead haha (maybe like a Peralta and a SP[Carpenter/Gio] for Beltre?). But anyway, out of these two, which one should project to provide better fantasy value over the course of the season? Any thoughts? Thanks!!

C Yadier Molina
1B Ryan howard
2B Brandon Phillips
3B Jhonny Peralta
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Matt Kemp
OF Carlos Quentin
OF Rajai Davis
Util Corey Hart
BN Vladimir Guerrero
BN Alex Rios

SP Roy Halladay
SP Chris Carpenter
SP Jair Jurrjens
RP Sergio Santos
RP Mark Melancon
P Gio Gonzalez
P Brian Matusz
P Charlie Morton
P Phil Humber
P Mike Adams
P Aaron Crow
DL Brandon McCarthy

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd rather have Peralta.

[RedHopeful]

I'd rather have Peralta.

Likewise.

[baegames]

I'd rather have Peralta but I may rather have Roberts than Alex Rios. You will then have a backup at every position but Catcher and First Base.

Roberts can be the backup at 2b, 3b, and of. If you lose Rollins, shift Peralta to SS, start Roberts at 3b; for OF, move Hart to OF, Roberts to UT. And I'd rather have a 1b than Vlad the Impaler.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=433188

[DattKemp27]

I would choose Peralta over the two but mabye you should keep Roberts too. I see Rios on your bench and i would have no problem dumping Rios and keeping Roberts.

If you would be able to help
viewtopic.php?t=433261