Please rate, will see yours

[canibus]

Please rate this motley crew
16 teams ROTO 5x5 with OBP instead of BA
 
Pos Batters H/AB R HR RBI SB OBP
C J. Kendall (Pit - C)  191/587 84 6 58 8 .399
 1B J. Phillips (NYM - C,1B) 120/403 45 11 58 0 .373
 2B M. Giles (Atl - 2B)  174/551 101 21 69 14 .390
 3B M. Ensberg (Hou - 3B)  112/385 69 25 60 7 .377
 SS Á. Berroa (KC - SS)  163/567 92 17 73 21 .338
 OF M. Ramírez (Bos - LF,DH) 185/569 117 37 104 3 .427
 OF P. Wilson (Col - CF)  169/600 94 36 141 14 .343
 OF B. Giles (SD - LF,CF)  147/492 93 20 88 4 .427
 Util G. Jenkins (Mil - LF)  144/487 81 28 95 0 .375
 BN E. Durazo (Oak - 1B,DH)  139/537 92 21 77 1 .374
 BN T. Redman (Pit - CF) 76/230 36 3 19 7 .374
 
Pos Pitchers IP W SV K ERA WHIP
 SP B. Zito (Oak - SP) 231.2 14 0 146 3.30 1.18
 SP K. Millwood (Phi - SP)  222.0 14 0 169 4.01 1.25
 RP D. Riske (Cle - RP)  74.2 2 8 82 2.29 0.96
 RP J. Valverde (Ari - RP) 50.1 2 10 71 2.15 0.99
 P J. Affeldt (KC - SP,RP) 126.0 7 4 98 3.93 1.30
 P J. Weaver (LA - SP,RP)  159.1 7 0 93 5.99 1.62
 P O. Villarreal (Ari - RP)  98.0 10 0 80 2.57 1.29
 BN R. Nen (SF - RP)  0 0 0 0 0 0
 BN J. Williams (SF - SP)  131.0 7 0 88 3.30 1.26
 BN B. Donnelly (Ana - RP)  74.0 2 3 79 1.58 1.07
 BN C. Bradford (Oak - RP)  77.0 7 2 62 3.04 1.26
 BN D. Brazelton (TB - SP)  48.1 1 0 24 6.89 1.66

 

[Quaker]

Very nice OF, shaky IF. Is there no better option at 1st than Phillips? I drafted Phillips, but I think his only value is at C. If Ensberg and Berroa play like they did last year (with Ensberg not platooning), and Giles can come close to what he did, your hitting will be fine. However, I'm not sold on Giles, and the other two could easily slump.

Your first two pitchers are good- I think they will both pitch better than they did last year- but it's steeply downhill from there. Weaver needs to pitch to his potential and Affeldt needs to stay away from blisters for you to have a shot at most categories. Brazelton is garbage, even in a 16 team league. You'll be hurting for saves, even if Nen is healthy.

The only thing I'd look at right now is 1b. For everything else, it'll be hard to do anything because with 16 teams there probably aren't many options on the WW. Just wait until the season starts.

[Pokeyouindaeye]

I think you should sub durazo in for phillips at the moment and hope that durazo heats up. Also try to pick up herges, so you get those saves until nen returns. You might also want to put in jerome williams for either villareal or weaver until they put some decent numbers up.

[The Indestructible]

I'm not too high on either Preston Wilson or Zito, so if I had your team, I'd look to trade both of them. I'd definitely consider a 2-1 with Zito. But then again, Zito could turn out to be just fine.