I was just offered Max Scherzer for my B.J. Upton and Michael Cuddyer. Upton and Cuddyer are both kind of "on the fence" of cracking my starting lineup (Cuddyer has been starting for me lately). I'm pretty short on pitching, which is why I'm considering it. But is it good value for Scherzer? Leave a link, and I'll give you my all. Standard 12 team 5X5 yahoo league, 4 man keeper.
C- Russell Martin 1B - Mark Teixeira 2B - Michael Cuddyer 3B - Kevin Youklis SS - Jimmy Rollins OF - Andrew McCutchen OF - Jay Bruce OF - Andre Ethier Util. - B.J. Upton SP - Felix Hernandez SP - Jered Weaver SP - Mat Latos RP - Craig Kimbrel RP - Matt Capps P - Sergio Santos P - Kyle Farnsworth Bench - Eric Hosmer Bench - J.J. Hardy Bench - Placido Polanco Bench - Geovany Soto Bench (DL) - Brian Roberts Bench (P) - Chad Billingsley Bench (P) - Rubby de la Rosa Bench (P) - Jordan Zimmermann Bench (P) - Frank Francisco
Beautiful, Beautiful Family Guy
Lois: You're drunk again.
Peter: No, I'm just exhausted 'cause I've been up all night drinking.
Definitely do this trade, you can find players on the FA that will give you numbers better then BJ's right now. So essentially it is Cuddyer for Scherzer which is a great trade for you, especially since you need pitching.
No way I do this trade. Cuddyer is heating up, Upton can garner you some quality on name alone with some power, runs, rbi's and steals, and you're getting a pitcher that has an ERA over 4 and a .279 BAA....... No thanks!
I thin Upton for Shcherzer 1-for-1 is fair but (1) Upton is your only real SB threat outside of McCutchen....Rolllins doesn't run much anymore, and (2) if you're losing BOTH BJ and Scherzer I'd go for a slightly better SP.