Dynasty League? Yes, please.
In almost every situation where a closer can be traded for a stud offensive force, (and it will not hurt dramatically in the current year), you make the deal in a dynasty league.
Especially in the case where the closer in question is:
(1) in their first year with the job at a position with tons of turnover
(2) has been struggling lately
(3) plays for a Manager who has never kept his closer consistently. How many times did Bobby Jenks lose and then regain his job?
Help with mine:viewtopic.php?t=432277