Chacin/LoMo for Zimmerman/Pagan/Lowrie? WHIR

[Bea Arthur]

20 team H2H (OBP vs AVG), keeper league (5 keepers)

I'm pretty thin at SS since I lost Furcal and Aviles got sent down. Do this trade to get Lowrie, along with Jordan Zimmerman and Pagan for Chacin and LoMo? I like LoMo, but Pagan might end up just as good if not better (more steals). Zimmerman is underrated too, I just worry a little about an innings limit. What do you think? WHIR for sure.

My lineup:

C- Carlos Santana
1B - Votto
2B - Cano
SS - Scutaro/A. Casilla
3B - C. McGhee
OF - Crawford
OF - Crisp
OF - LoMo
UTIL - Hosmer
BN - Furcal
BN - Heyward (DL)
SP - G. Gonzalez
SP - Chacin
SP - Garza
SP - Zambrano
SP - C. Carrasco
RP - Soria
RP - Santos
RP - Walden

[BiGAnT]

I wouldn't do this if I were you...I like Chacin a lot and even though Zimmerman has looked good, I like Chacin much better. And LoMo is going to be better than Pagan, regardless of steals...Pagan is just not himself and I don't see a turn around to the point where it would make him better than LoMo...also, is Dee Gordon available for SS (I see its a 20 team league but I figure its worth asking)?? He would be a great source of SB if thats what you're looking for and he would be perfect since you need a SS anyway, rather than have to do this for Lowrie who may not play everyday anyway. I would say stick with where you're at right now though, good luck!

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=433037

[emeraldcitysaints]

100% Agree, I don't see the value in this deal. Lowrie is very risky right now given that he has played poorly as of late and may even be battling injuries. Zimmerman has a history of injuries and is by no means as dynamic as JC. Pagan has also been out this year so to me it looks like a ton of risk with very little upside compared to what you have.

Help on mine - viewtopic.php?t=433043

[Bea Arthur]

What about if I drop the Chacin/Zimmerman aspect, so it's just Lowrie/Pagan for LoMo?

[facekdr]

"Lowrie is very risky right now given that he has played poorly as of late and may even be battling injuries."

I agree with this. I would want a little more return for Morrison.

[mshimmyb]

I would look else where... I like LoMo and Chacin MUCH better then PAgan/Zimm... If anyone like Escobar, Hardy, Theriot, Gonzalez, Infante, etc. is availabel as FA or Waiver, they could bring you as much production as Lowrie... look to FA... Rubin Tejada? Dee Gordon would be great too

[jpbusta]

I don't like it. Did you lose out on Dee Gordon?

I'd try to work something else out. Just seems like you're losing out especially when Lowrie seems to be losing playing time under Scutaro's return.