Marcum/Jurrjens/Hosmer for Shields/Ogando/Quentin? WHIR

[JJGBPD]

I would be getting Shields, Ogando and Quentin. Pitching seems like a wash although I think overall Marcum is the best pitcher in the deal. I would use Quentin in utility spot over Hosmer for more pop. Thoughts?? Thanks!

[rjforlife]

Marcum is easily over Shields, not terribly close if you ask me.

Jurrjens vs. Ogando is close but I still give the nod to Jurrjens.

Hosmer to Quentin is an upgrade but nothing major, Hosmer looks pretty damn solid, while Quentin is a wildcard. Edge to you but only by a bit.



Overall it's only a mediocre trade, and one that I wouldn't do. You need a more proven arm if you are giving up Marcum, or someone that contributes in more than 2 categories, which is really all Quentin brings to the table.


Help:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=432878

[JJGBPD]

Okay, so what about I give Marcum/Jurrjens and get Shields and Granderson?? It hurts my pitching, but I could always grab a Bud Norris, Brandon Morrow, Brian Matusz off waivers. I need SB and Granderson helps in atleast 3 categories... thoughts?

[ensanimal]

Okay, so what about I give Marcum/Jurrjens and get Shields and Granderson?? It hurts my pitching, but I could always grab a Bud Norris, Brandon Morrow, Brian Matusz off waivers. I need SB and Granderson helps in atleast 3 categories... thoughts?

If you can handle the pitching loss, I like this deal much better than the first one posted. With some of the guys you posted available as well, you should be able to patch some solid starts together.

[MadDog36]

Ogando is no slouch. Shields is quietly having a solid season and Quentin is a beast, I'd do it.
Shields, Ogando and Quentin

[irollaround]

I like the second deal, don't like the first deal at all. Especially with you saying the talent that is available in FA.

Help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=432982